Chapter 2

I stumbled out of the conference room on unsteady legs, my vision tunneling as colleagues' voices faded into meaningless noise. The hallway stretched endlessly before me, fluorescent lights buzzing overhead like angry wasps.

The bathroom door felt impossibly heavy. I shoved it open and barely made it to the nearest stall before my knees buckled. The cold tile bit through my skirt as I collapsed, my phone still clutched in my trembling hands.

The screen glowed accusingly. Donor #3847. Ethan Mitchell. My husband's face staring back at me from a fertility clinic database.

I pressed my back against the stall door, gulping air that tasted metallic. My mind raced, fragments of memory colliding like broken glass.

Five years ago. "Let's start trying," I'd whispered into Ethan's neck after dinner, wine making me bold. His smile had been so bright, so genuine. "I can't wait to see you as a mom, Harper."

Four years ago. The devastating appointment with Dr. Reeves. Ethan's hand crushing mine as she delivered the news: "I'm sorry, Mr. Mitchell. The test results show complete infertility. Natural conception isn't possible."

I remembered his tears. The way his shoulders shook as he apologized, as if his body's betrayal was somehow his fault. "We'll figure this out," I'd promised, stroking his hair. "There are options."

Donor conception. The hardest decision of our lives, made together in that sterile office.

Except it had all been a lie.

My fingers flew across the phone screen, scrolling through donation records with manic precision. March 15th, three years ago. The first entry. One week after Ethan's "devastating" follow-up appointment.

Three years ago. Megan's surprise announcement at our monthly book club meeting. "I'm pregnant!" she'd laughed, her hand pressed to her still-flat stomach. "Can you believe it? After all these years of being single, I finally meet someone and boom—instant family."

I'd hugged her so tight, genuinely happy despite my own struggles. "Who's the father?"

"Just some guy from a dating app. We broke up already—he wasn't ready for this kind of commitment." Her smile had been radiant. "But I am. I'm going to be a single mom, and I can't wait."

Two years ago. Lucas's birth. Seven pounds, three ounces of perfect baby boy. I'd held him in the hospital, tears streaming down my face as Megan beamed from the bed.

"Look at those eyes," I'd whispered. Green eyes that seemed familiar somehow. "He's going to be a heartbreaker."

"Harper, would you be his godmother? I can't think of anyone I'd trust more."

Godmother. To my husband's son.

One year ago. Megan's second pregnancy announcement. "The same guy?" I'd asked, surprised.

"We tried to make it work," she'd shrugged. "But some men just aren't built for family life. At least Lucas will have a sibling."

Six months ago. Lily's birth. Another perfect baby with Ethan's distinctive eye color. I'd thrown Megan a baby shower, bought tiny clothes, assembled a crib.

Three months ago. My own positive pregnancy test after years of failure. Ethan's joy had seemed so genuine, his tears of happiness so real.

"Finally," he'd whispered, pulling me close. "Our miracle baby."

Our miracle baby. Conceived through anonymous donor conception that had somehow, impossibly, matched me with my own husband.

I lurched forward, dry heaving into the toilet. The irony was suffocating. Five years of trying. Dozens of negative tests. Hormone injections that made me crazy. Invasive procedures that left me raw and empty.

And the first time I'd gotten pregnant was when I'd used Ethan's sperm without knowing it.

My hands shook as I opened Instagram, searching for Megan's profile. Her feed was a shrine to single motherhood—artfully posed photos of her with Lucas and Lily, captions about the strength of women raising children alone.

But now I saw what I'd missed before. The background details. The helpful friend who appeared in so many shots, just out of focus. The man pushing Lucas on swings, teaching him to ride a bike, reading bedtime stories.

Ethan. Always Ethan.

"Uncle Ethan's here!" Lucas would shriek whenever we visited. The boy would launch himself into my husband's arms like they shared some secret connection.

Because they did. Blood connection. Father and son.

I scrolled frantically through photos, my vision blurring. There—Lucas's third birthday party last month. The camera had caught Ethan lifting the boy high in the air, both of them laughing. The resemblance was unmistakable now that I knew to look for it. The same nose, the same stubborn cowlick, the same way they both scrunched their eyes when they smiled.

How had I missed it? How had I been so blind?

Another photo. Lily's christening two months ago. Megan in white, holding her daughter. And there in the background, Ethan's profile as he watched them with an expression I'd never seen before. Tender. Possessive. Proud.

The look of a father watching his child.

My phone buzzed. A text from Ethan: "Left work early. Stopped at the baby store—couldn't resist looking at cribs! See you soon, mama. ❤️"

Mama. The word that had filled me with such joy this morning now felt like mockery.

I pressed my palm against my still-flat stomach. Twelve weeks along. The first successful pregnancy in five years of trying. The miracle we'd prayed for.

But it wasn't a miracle. It was just genetics. The same genetics that had given Megan two healthy children while I'd believed myself cursed with infertility.

The bathroom door creaked open. Footsteps echoed against tile.

"Harper? Honey, are you in here?" Jennifer's concerned voice drifted over the stall doors.

I couldn't answer. Couldn't move. My entire world had shifted on its axis in the span of thirty minutes.

Five years of lies. Five years of watching my best friend raise my husband's children while I mourned my empty womb. Five years of believing I was broken while Ethan played the devoted, supportive husband.

The supporting husband who'd been sabotaging our attempts to conceive while secretly fathering children with my best friend.

My hand tightened protectively over my abdomen. This baby—our baby, his baby—was the only truth I had left.

And somehow, that made everything infinitely worse.

Chapter 3

I didn't go home. I couldn't face Ethan's excited smile, his talk of cribs and baby names, not when everything I thought I knew had shattered in that conference room.

Instead, I found myself standing outside the Pacific Fertility Center as the afternoon sun cast long shadows across the parking lot. The building looked smaller than I remembered, less imposing than it had during those desperate months when it represented our last hope.

The receptionist's smile faltered when she saw my face. "Mrs. Mitchell? Is everything alright? You look—"

"I need my complete medical file," I interrupted, my voice hoarse from the bathroom breakdown. "Everything. Every test, every procedure, every note."

"I'm sorry, but we typically require advance notice for complete file requests—"

"The database was breached." The words came out flat, emotionless. "Donor information is all over the internet. I think you can make an exception."

Her face went pale. She glanced around the empty waiting room, then leaned closer. "Let me get Dr. Reeves."

Twenty minutes later, I sat across from the woman who'd guided us through three failed IVF cycles. Dr. Reeves looked older than I remembered, stress lines deepening around her eyes as she spread my thick file across her desk.

"Harper, I want you to know that we're taking the breach very seriously. Our legal team is—"

"I don't care about lawsuits." I pulled the file toward me, my hands steady now. "I want to understand why I failed three times and then succeeded on the fourth."

She hesitated. "Sometimes these things just... happen. The fourth cycle used different protocols—"

"Different protocols, or a different donor?"

The silence stretched between us. Dr. Reeves' fingers drummed against her desk, a nervous habit I'd never noticed before.

"The fourth cycle used anonymous donor sperm," she admitted finally. "Your husband... he was very involved in the selection process for the first three cycles."

Very involved. The phrase sent ice through my veins.

I flipped through the pages with mechanical precision. Consent forms signed in Ethan's careful handwriting. Treatment plans he'd approved. Notes in the margins I'd never seen.

Then I found them. Dr. Reeves' clinical notes, written in her precise script:

*Cycle 1: Patient's husband specifically requested Grade B embryos despite availability of Grade A options. Explained quality differences, but he insisted on 'not wanting to get hopes up too high.'*

*Cycle 2: Mr. Mitchell again selected lower-grade embryos. When questioned, stated he wanted to 'manage expectations realistically.'*

*Cycle 3: Husband inquired about medications that might affect implantation. Provided standard list of contraindicated drugs. Patient experienced implantation failure despite optimal conditions.*

My vision blurred. The pages rustled as my hands began to shake.

"He chose the worst embryos," I whispered.

"Harper—"

"Every single time, he chose the ones least likely to survive." The realization hit me like a physical blow. "And he asked about drugs that would prevent implantation."

Dr. Reeves reached across the desk, but I jerked away from her touch.

"Where's Sarah Chen? The nurse who assisted with my cycles?"

"She left the practice six months ago. Harper, I think you should—"

"I need her contact information."

"I can't give out personal information about former employees—"

"Then call her. Now."

The authority in my voice surprised us both. Dr. Reeves stared at me for a long moment, then picked up her phone.

Sarah agreed to meet me at a coffee shop near the clinic. She looked different outside the medical setting—younger, more vulnerable in jeans and a sweater instead of scrubs.

"I shouldn't be talking to you about this," she said, stirring her latte with nervous energy.

"Please." I leaned forward, my voice barely above a whisper. "I just need to understand."

Sarah's eyes darted around the nearly empty café. "Your husband... he asked a lot of questions. More than most partners do."

"What kind of questions?"

"Medical ones. About the procedures, the medications, the timing." She paused, her spoon clinking against ceramic. "He asked about drug interactions. What medications might interfere with implantation."

"What did you tell him?"

"The standard list. Blood thinners, certain antibiotics, high doses of vitamin C. I thought he was being careful, you know? Making sure you didn't accidentally take something that would hurt your chances."

My coffee grew cold as she continued.

"But then there were the embryo selections. Every cycle, he'd study the lab reports for hours. Dr. Reeves would recommend the highest-grade embryos, but he always found reasons to choose different ones. Said he didn't want to 'waste the good ones' if your body wasn't ready."

"Waste the good ones," I repeated.

"I remember thinking it was sweet, how protective he was. How he didn't want you to get your hopes up with perfect embryos if there might be other factors affecting success." Sarah's voice grew smaller. "But now, with everything that's happened..."

"The two miscarriages. The early losses."

"He came to the clinic alone before both of those. Said he wanted to pick up your medication refills, save you the trip." She met my eyes finally. "Harper, I'm not saying anything definitive. But the timing..."

The coffee shop spun around me. Five years. Five years of failed cycles, of tears, of believing my body was broken. Five years of Ethan holding me while I sobbed, whispering reassurances about trying again, about not giving up hope.

While he systematically sabotaged every attempt.

"The fourth cycle," I managed. "Why was it different?"

"Anonymous donor. You insisted on it, remember? Said you wanted to try a completely different approach. Your husband... he seemed upset about that decision. Said he wanted to be more involved in the selection process."

"But he couldn't be. Because he didn't know the donor was him."

Sarah nodded slowly. "The irony is... cruel. The one time he couldn't interfere was the one time it worked."

I sat in my car outside the coffee shop as darkness fell, staring at my phone. Ethan had sent six more texts, each one more concerned than the last.

*"Where are you? You missed dinner."*

*"Harper, please call me. I'm worried."*

*"The Thai food is getting cold. Are you okay?"*

*"Baby, you're scaring me. Just let me know you're safe."*

Baby. The word that used to make my heart flutter now felt like acid in my throat.

Five years. Five years of injections that made me bloated and emotional. Five years of invasive procedures and crushing disappointments. Five years of questioning my worth as a woman, as a wife, as a potential mother.

Five years of Ethan comforting me through failures he had orchestrated.

This wasn't infidelity. This wasn't even betrayal in any conventional sense.

This was something far worse. This was the systematic murder of our unborn children, carried out by the man who'd sworn to love and protect me.

And the only reason I was finally pregnant was because, for once, he hadn't been able to kill what was growing inside me.

Unlock Now
Show your support to inspire the writer to come up with more fantastic stories

The Donor Was My Husband

Chapter 2 : Cecilia
Chapters
Customize
Next Chapter