What was so hard about her life?

She breezed through eight years of school without a care in the world, landed a job at a design firm right after graduation, and had a bright future stretching out ahead of her.

I'd slaved away for thirteen years. My body was wrecked, my looks destroyed, and because I never finished middle school, I couldn't even qualify for the easier positions.

If anything, I wished I'd been the one sent to live with relatives.

I was shaking with rage. Desiree wrapped her arms around me, her voice gentle and soothing.

"Letitia, if you need to blame someone, blame me. Please don't blame Egbert."

"We're truly in love. I'm begging you, give us your blessing."

Everyone looked at her with approval, admiring her kindness. Even knowing she was superior to me in every way, in looks and education, she was still willing to be considerate of my feelings. A failure's feelings.

But what no one noticed was that the words Desiree whispered in my ear told a very different story.

"Letitia, let me tell you something."

"Thirteen years ago, we both got a fried egg. You got yours at the dinner table. I got mine in the kitchen. Mom said if it weren't for the fact that you absolutely had to have one, both of them would've been mine."

"And last night, my noodles had two eggs. Yours had none."

So that bowl of egg noodles had nothing to do with reward or punishment. It was nothing but our parents playing favorites, through and through.

My eyes nearly split with fury. But she held me tight, her arms like a vise.

"Egbert wrote you letters. I intercepted every single one. I went after him on purpose, made him fall for me little by little."

"If I'd known you'd come back from the frontier looking like this, I wouldn't have even bothered pretending. Because right now, you're not even worth comparing to me."

The moment the words left her mouth, she staggered back two steps and tumbled down the stairs.

Mom slapped me so hard my head snapped to the side. "If anything happens to Desiree, I will never forgive you!"

Dad looked stricken with grief. "You'd lay hands on your own sister over a man? Are you even human?"

Egbert's face was full of disappointment. "Your sister told me your personality had changed, and I didn't believe her. Now I see she was being generous. You're vicious."

I pressed my hand to my burning cheek. The hatred inside me burrowed from my heart into my bones like worms, gnawing, flaying me alive.

If it weren't for me, our parents never would have made it back from the frontier in one piece.

If it weren't for me, Egbert would have died at three years old.

That day, I flipped the table. I screamed like a madwoman, pouring out every injustice festering inside me.

"Mom! You remember that Desiree loves peanuts, but you don't even know I'm allergic to them! I was hospitalized ten times for allergic reactions. Three of those times I nearly died!"

"Dad! All you ever did was hold Desiree and paint with her. All I ever got was cold words. 'You're too stupid. Instead of wasting time learning to paint, you should help out around the house so you can find a good man to marry someday.' We're both your daughters! Why did you treat us so differently?"

"Egbert, we grew up together! You promised you'd never marry anyone but me. I will die before I agree to let you marry Desiree!"

The room went terrifyingly silent.

Everyone stared at me. There was no shock at our parents' favoritism. No judgment of Desiree for benefiting from it all.

Only disgust at me for being ungrateful.

Dad looked at me quietly, the way you'd look at a child throwing a senseless tantrum.

"Letitia, you've gone too far. Making this kind of scene over a wedding? Where's your dignity? Your mother and I have always treated you and your sister equally. We've never played favorites. You had bad luck and didn't get the egg. Why are you taking it out on your sister?"

"I'm telling you right now: Egbert doesn't want you. You will accept that."

In the end, I was locked away as punishment.

Six days in a pitch-black room with no light.

No one brought water. No one brought food. I starved to death.

In the last moment before my eyes closed for good, all I could hear were firecrackers shaking the sky. Everyone was celebrating Desiree and Egbert's wedding.

...

Inside, Mom and Desiree were still whispering to each other, glancing my way every so often.

I put away the dishes and went to my room.

I spent the entire night doing the math.

Early the next morning, Egbert arrived with Boris Gilbert and Mila Gilbert in tow.

Dad wore a brand-new formal suit, looking every bit the polished intellectual. Mom and Desiree were dressed in matching polyester outfits, like a pair of sisters.

And me? All I had was the ill-fitting dress Desiree had tossed my way the night before, looking down her nose as she did it.

Surrounded by a room full of well-groomed, educated people, I stuck out like a sore thumb.

Boris and Mila stared at me with eyes that nearly bulged out of their heads. Egbert looked three parts disbelief and seven parts disgust.

Then my mother spoke up with a bright smile. "In-laws, I've adored Egbert ever since he was a boy. I can't tell you how happy I am that our Desiree gets to marry him!"

Mila's eyes lit up. "It's Desiree who's marrying him?"

My mother clasped Mila's hands and let out a sigh, putting on a pained expression.

"I know we originally agreed on Letitia. But the poor girl's had a hard life. Thirteen years with us out on the frontier, and look what it's done to her..."

"Thankfully, she's sensible. She knows the gap between herself and Egbert, so she offered to step aside and let Desiree and Egbert be together. She even said she'd go find work and save up her own dowry!"

Boris and Mila looked briefly surprised, then turned to me with a gaze that was equal parts approval and pity. They praised me for being sensible, for seeing the bigger picture, for being a good little sister.

I didn't say a word. I just helped pour tea and serve water while they happily discussed the wedding plans.

Because I knew that making a scene would be pointless. My death in my previous life had taught me that much.

Egbert let out a long breath of relief and stepped toward me.

"Letitia, I owe you. If you ever need anything, don't hesitate to come to me."

I pulled away from his reach and let out a cold laugh. "No need."

In this life, we would have nothing to do with each other.

Desiree clung to Egbert's arm, triumphant.

"Little sister, I know you resent me for stealing Egbert away. But love doesn't follow a first-come, first-served rule."

"Stop sulking. Egbert's transfer orders have already come through. You work hard for a couple of years, save up your dowry, and we'll absolutely find you a man with a proper government job."

"The transfer orders came through? That's wonderful! Our Desiree's going to be a bureaucrat's wife!" Mom and Dad slapped their thighs in delight, then turned to me. "Letitia, didn't you save up thirty dollars? Hurry up and take your sister and brother-in-law to a nice restaurant to celebrate!"

They shoved at me, their eyes darting greedily to the pocket at my waist.

I stood rooted to the spot and shook my head. "I won't."

"What did you just say?"

I stared straight into my mother's face and spoke slowly, one word at a time. "You traded away my engagement. Why should I pay for the celebration?"

"If you want me to treat, fine. First, pay back the eight hundred and fifty-two dollars and thirty-five cents you owe me."

The room went dead silent.

My mother's face flushed red. She understood perfectly. I had refused their demand and challenged their authority as parents.

Her expression twisted into something ugly right before everyone's eyes. Her hand moved faster than her brain, and the slap cracked across my face before the words even left her mouth.

"Letitia Sullivan! What kind of nonsense are you spouting?!"

"It's not nonsense." I wiped the blood from the corner of my mouth and looked at her calmly. "I have the IOUs. Signed by you, with your thumbprint."

Because Dad once praised Desiree for having a talent for painting, I had thrown myself into practicing calligraphy until my handwriting was flawless.

Over those thirteen years, I finished my labor during the day, then burned through lamp oil at night, copying books for people and collecting scraps for money. In total, I had earned nine hundred dollars.

The neighbors all praised me for being clever and capable, a girl who could work hard and earn her keep.

And gradually, some of them began to speak up for me.

"Hey, Mr. and Mrs. Sullivan, you two sure have it made. You work your daughter like a mule while you sit inside painting pictures and reading books. Must be nice. The rest of us aren't nearly so lucky."

That evening, the moment I got off work, my mother dragged me into the house and slapped me hard across the face.

"You just love playing the saint, don't you? Help your parents with a few chores and suddenly the whole village's singing your praises and pointing fingers at us behind our backs!"

"Fine! From now on, every cent we spend, we'll write you an IOU. When we earn the money, we'll pay back every last penny!"

I went into my room, a converted storage shed, and brought out a cookie tin.

I opened it. Inside was a stack of IOUs nearly two inches thick.

Dates, signatures, red thumbprints.

Every single one accounted for.

My parents froze in place, staring at that stack, their lips pressed into thin lines.

Everyone else fell dead silent, exchanging uneasy glances.

I picked up the one on top and read it aloud, slowly. "I, Jack Sullivan, hereby owe Letitia Sullivan $11.80 for the purchase of paintbrushes. This note serves as proof."

"Starting from March 1970. Eleven years' worth."

"Jack Sullivan and Olivia Lawrence borrowed a total of $825.35 from me."

"Of that, $169.43 went to medicine when they were sick. $483.55 went to painting supplies and books. And $172.37 covered everyday expenses."

"Oh, and one more thing. When we moved back to the city, you borrowed another fifty dollars from me. Bought Dad a formal suit. You and Desiree each got yourselves a new blouse. You said you'd write me an IOU when we got home."

With every item I read, another shade of color drained from my parents' faces.

Boris and Mila Gilbert, along with Egbert, had started out looking shocked and confused. But as they followed my words and their eyes landed on the formal suit and the blouses the three of them were wearing, that confusion curdled into disbelief and visible discomfort.

My mother opened her mouth, trying to cut me off, but she was so furious no sound came out.

My father swung his hand and slapped me across the face. Every trace of his mild-mannered, scholarly composure was gone. He jabbed a finger at my nose, his voice shrill and cracking.

"Letitia Sullivan! Your parents gave you life and raised you, and you're sitting here nickel-and-diming us over every last cent? You ungrateful little wretch!"

They hadn't held back.

Both my cheeks were split and bleeding.

Thirteen years ago, the first time they'd hit me, I hadn't been able to take it. I'd passed out for a full day and night.

Things were different now. I'd grown up.

Not only could I take both slaps, I had the nerve to shatter the chains and set myself free.

I pressed my tongue against the torn flesh inside my cheek, then let out a quiet laugh.

"Mom, Dad. That first time we drew lots with the fried eggs... was I really the only one who got one?"

"And last night, didn't Desiree eat two?"