Chapter 2

I tapped the encrypted folder labeled Sundays.

Scott lunged across the dining table. His palm slapped hard against the smart screen, turning the display pitch black. The force of his hand rattled the crystal wine glasses.

"Why does a harmless chat need a separate password, Scott?" Ben asked.

Scott stared at the dark glass under his hand, his jaw clamped shut. He offered no explanation. His silence answered the question for him.

I did not wait for him to find his voice. I bypassed the console entirely, unlocking my own phone. As the co-administrator of our home server, my credentials overrode his manual lock. The screen loaded instantly. Six hundred and twelve messages populated my display, sorted chronologically.

"Ben, send the kids home," Paige pleaded, her voice cracking as she stepped away from the table. "We shouldn't do this here."

"They are upstairs with noise-canceling headphones on," Ben replied, his tone flat. "I am not building you a private interrogation room."

I scrolled to the very top of the thread. Two years ago.

"Talking to you makes me feel seen," I read aloud, quoting Paige's exact text from a Sunday night.

I scrolled down three months later.

"When the kids are older, we can rearrange our lives," I read. "That was your reply, Scott."

Scott pulled his hand away from the blank console. "Hannah, you are taking lines out of context."

I kept scrolling. My thumb stopped on a block of data from eighteen months ago. A continuous call log.

"One seventeen in the morning," I said, looking directly at Paige. "A ninety-minute phone call. You told me he was helping you draft the charity gala proposal that night."

Paige crossed her arms over her chest, shrinking back.

I remembered that specific morning. Ben had questioned the late-night notifications on her phone. I had stood right here in this dining room and defended her. I had looked Ben in the eye and told him Paige would never lie to me. My trust had been the perfect cover, and I had handed it to them myself.

"Why did you use Hannah as a shield?" Ben asked Paige.

Paige wiped a tear from her cheek, glaring at her husband. "You haven't looked at me in years, Ben. You froze me out of our marriage. Scott just filled the empty space you left behind."

Scott pointed a finger at me across the table. "And you treat this house like a second studio. You never stop working. We were lonely, Hannah."

"You used my money to save your career," I said. "And you used my friendship to hide your affair."

A crash echoed from the wooden staircase.

Chloe stood on the landing. Shards of a broken water glass scattered around her bare feet, water seeping into the oak floorboards.

"Did you really discuss where we would live?" Chloe asked.

Scott rushed toward the stairs, extending both arms. "Sweetie, let me explain."

Chloe took a step backward. Her heel narrowly missed a jagged piece of glass. She shrank against the wall, pulling away from her father. The lie about protecting the kids had already failed.

"We never touched," Paige cried out, stepping toward Ben. "No kisses. No hotels. We didn't do anything physical."

Scott dropped his arms as Chloe retreated further up the stairs. "We were just talking through possibilities. Trying to figure out a more honest future for everyone."

"Honest?" I asked. "You secretly planned out houses, step-parents, and weekend custody schedules behind our backs, and you call that honest?"

Neither of them answered.

Ben reached into his pocket, pulled out his phone, and placed it flat on the mahogany table.

"We each keep a read-only copy of this drive," Ben said, looking at me. "We both hire lawyers tomorrow morning. And we do not use the kids as messengers."

"I agree," I said. "And no one deletes the parts that make them look bad."

Scott let out a dry, bitter laugh. "Look at you two. The victims, already forming an alliance."

Paige stared at Ben. He stood close to my chair, his shoulder hovering near mine.

I grabbed the wooden frame of my chair and dragged it half a step away from Ben. I refused to let Scott spin a new narrative, and I refused to let shared trauma push me into leaning on another man.

I opened my email application, attached the raw archive file, and typed in Maya Brooks. She handled all the legal contracts for my studio.

I hit send.

My phone buzzed a minute later. Maya confirmed receipt. The original timestamps were now locked in her legal server.

Scott's posture shifted. The defensive guilt vanished from his face, replaced by a cold, hard stare.

"You copied our private data without consent," Scott said, his voice dropping the gentle tone entirely. "Delete it, Hannah. Now. Before midnight."

I walked past him toward the hallway. "No one is choosing parents tonight. You are sleeping in the study."

Ben grabbed Paige's coat from the rack by the door and tossed it to her. "Let's go, Paige."

I did not wait to watch them leave. I walked up the stairs, checked on the kids in their rooms, and stepped into the master bedroom. I pushed the door shut and turned the deadbolt. The heavy brass lock clicked into place. For the first time in our marriage, Scott was locked out of our shared space.

My phone screen flared bright in the dark room. A system alert popped up over my lock screen.

Remote wipe requested at 11:42 p.m.

The request originated from Scott's device. He was trying to erase the home server from the study.

I pressed reject.

A warning text flashed across the screen. Three failed attempts will freeze the administrator account for thirty days.

Another alert pinged immediately. The second wipe request.

Heavy footsteps stopped right outside my bedroom door.

"Cancel your lawyer's access before twelve," Scott said through the wood. "Or I tell the kids you chose to give this family to the courts."

Chapter 3

"The kids will know we share the consequences of this," I told the heavy bedroom door. "I won't let you tell them I handed this family to a judge."

My phone buzzed in my palm. The third remote wipe request failed. A red banner flashed across my screen.

Administrator account frozen for thirty days.

On the other side of the brass lock, Scott let out a curse. A heavy thud rattled the wood as he struck the frame with his fist. His footsteps retreated down the hall, fading into the carpet.

The next morning, the eight dirty place settings still sat in the kitchen sink. Dried tomato sauce clung to the porcelain.

Max stood by the island, his backpack slung over one shoulder. "Are Sunday dinners over forever?"

Scott poured black coffee into a travel mug. He wouldn't meet our son's eyes. "Things are just complicated right now, buddy."

"Don't do that," I said, stepping into the kitchen. "Give him a real answer."

Scott gripped the handle of his mug. "Hannah, not right now."

"Tell him," I pushed, keeping my voice level. "Tell him using one sentence. Do not mention Paige, and do not blame me."

Scott stared at the granite countertop. His jaw muscles flexed. "Mom needs space."

I walked over to Max and adjusted his backpack strap. "We both need honesty and space, Max. That means things will change."

Chloe walked in, catching the tail end of the exchange. She watched her father open his mouth to argue, then snap it shut. He looked at me, realizing I would no longer smooth over his rough edges. The silence stretched until the front door finally clicked shut behind the kids.

The doorbell rang twenty minutes later.

Ben stood on the porch, holding a sealed manila envelope and a silver flash drive. I let him in. He walked to the kitchen island and set the items down.

"The drive has my backup of the server," Ben said. "The envelope is something else."

I slid the paper out of the envelope. It was a Harbor House restaurant order form, dated ten months ago. Two columns of neat handwriting filled the back.

Reasons to stay. Reasons to leave.

"I wrote that before I found any texts," Ben said, staring at the paper. "I locked it in my desk. I never brought up separation with Paige."

I read the list. The first column mentioned the kids. The second column mentioned a dead bedroom and endless silence.

"I can't play the perfect, blindsided husband," Ben admitted, his voice dropping. "I keep wondering if I'm just using her betrayal as a convenient exit."

I placed the paper flat on the island. I did not offer him a comforting lie.

"Being unhappy explains a divorce," I told him. "It doesn't defend a secret plan to swap our lives behind our backs."

Ben nodded once, accepting the harsh truth. He pulled a pen from his pocket. "We need ground rules. If we are fighting them, we cannot fight each other."

"Separate lawyers," I said. "All evidence shared equally."

Ben wrote it down on the bottom of the order form. "The kids do not carry messages."

"No drinking together while the marriages are legally active," I added. "No physical contact."

Ben did not hesitate. He wrote down my boundaries, then added one of his own.

"If either of us feels too dependent on the other, we pause contact," he said, capping the pen.

My phone chimed on the counter. A massive block of text populated the neighborhood group chat. Paige's name sat at the top.

"Scott and I have just been supporting each other through difficult times," Paige wrote. "Hannah and Ben teamed up overnight to gather evidence against us. I just want peace for our children."

Three neighbors replied immediately, urging everyone to stay calm. Another neighbor canceled the block barbecue scheduled for Saturday. Silence from the rest of the group cemented Paige's narrative.

I did not upload the six hundred messages. I typed one reply.

"We will not debate child-related matters here. And we will not call a two-year secret a slip of the tongue."

A minute later, Ben's message appeared in the chat. He stated the same boundary, using different phrasing. We were aligned, but we had not copy-pasted a joint statement.

My screen switched to an incoming call. Mrs. Gable, the principal of the local private academy and a major client for Northlight Studio.

"Hannah," Mrs. Gable began, her tone clipped. "I saw the neighborhood chat. I need assurance that my students' portraits are stored on a secure server, separate from any domestic dispute evidence."

My stomach turned. Paige had weaponized my career in less than twelve hours.

"Your files are encrypted on a separate business drive, Mrs. Gable," I assured her. "Zero overlap."

I ended the call just as Scott walked into the kitchen. He pointed at my phone.

"Delete your reply," Scott demanded. "Apologize in the chat, say emotions ran high, and this stops."

"You want me to apologize for finding your texts?" I asked.

"I want you to stop burning down our social lives," he shot back. "Get on the video link. Paige and I have a proposal for the living arrangements."

I opened my laptop. Ben joined the call from his phone. Paige sat in her living room, her eyes red, dabbing her nose with a tissue.

Scott shared his screen, displaying a color-coded spreadsheet.

"It is called nesting," Scott explained, pointing to the grid. "The kids stay in their respective houses. The four of us rotate in and out. It provides maximum stability for them."

I looked at the assigned locations. The schedule put me on the sofa in my photography studio for four days a week. It placed Ben in the cramped back office of his restaurant. Scott and Paige, however, retained full weekend access to the primary houses.

"You two are the best at managing the mess," Paige offered through the speakers, her tone laced with artificial sympathy.

Chapter 4

"The document is empty, Hannah."

Maya's voice carried through my phone speaker, cutting through the quiet of my home office. I stared at the recovered file on my monitor. Only the title remained intact: Phase Three: Make Hannah and Ben think it was their idea.

Scott stood in the doorway, arms crossed over his chest. "It was Paige's twisted joke. You are turning a technical glitch into a marriage sentence."

"You left a joke in a hidden folder for twenty-two months?" I asked, turning my chair to face him. "And you decided to edit it last night at midnight?"

Scott dropped his arms. His eyes darted toward the timestamp on the screen. "I do not remember what I clicked during the argument."

"He wiped the body text," Maya said over the line. "The metadata confirms it existed, but we cannot prove the full intent with just a title. We need an earlier version."

"There is no earlier version," Scott snapped. "Because it was a fantasy."

"File for temporary financial and custody orders today," Maya instructed me, ignoring him entirely. "Do not let him use the joint accounts or the kids' schedules as leverage."

"Draw up the papers," I said. "But do not petition to strip his custody. Just freeze the current address and school enrollments. Neither of us moves the kids without written consent."

Scott exhaled sharply, turning on his heel and walking down the hall.

Maya waited until his footsteps faded. "Photograph the screen with a second device," she said. "Then export the access log before he changes another permission."

I used my studio camera, not my phone, and captured the title, timestamp, and empty document in one frame. Then I generated a checksum for the recovered file and emailed it to Maya. The body text was gone, but the deletion now had a documented time and an identified administrator.

"Do not confront him about any other devices," Maya warned. "People who think they are losing control often destroy the thing that proves it."

I disabled remote editing on the home archive but left read-only synchronization active. If an older copy existed on a school drive, event server, or shared tablet, the system could still surface it. That narrow opening was the only reason I agreed to attend the academy fundraiser the next day.

Two hours later, the bell above Northlight Studio's door chimed. Paige stepped into the reception area, her hands shoved deep into her coat pockets.

"I need my blue appointment book," Paige said.

I walked to the storage cabinet and pulled out the worn leather planner. Seven years ago, I had slapped twelve neon stickers on the cover to track her therapy sessions. The edges were frayed now.

"You saved me then," Paige said, her voice falling to a fragile whisper. "Why can't you save me again?"

I placed the book on the reception desk. "Those nineteen nights you slept in my guest room were not a debt you owed me. They were proof I considered you family."

Paige reached for the planner, her fingers trembling. "I just needed someone who would not judge me, Hannah."

"That is exactly why you used me as a shield eighteen months ago," I said. "You knew I would look Ben in the eye and lie about your late-night calls. You weaponized my trust."

She stepped forward, opening her arms for a hug.

I took a step backward, keeping the desk between us. "You were my best friend."

Paige flinched at the past tense. She grabbed the book and hurried out the glass door.

By nine that evening, the neon sign outside Harbor House clicked off. I sat at the empty mahogany bar. Ben walked out of the kitchen, setting two glasses of club soda on the polished wood. No wine. No bourbon.

My phone lit up on the counter. A text from Paige flashed across the screen, begging for a private conversation.

Ben read the notification. He did not curse. He did not raise his voice.

"Do you need to pause tonight?" Ben asked, wiping down the bar with a white towel. "We wrote down the rules. If this is too much, we stop."

"I just need to review the server log," I said, reaching for the printed stack of paper between us.

Ben reached for the same page. His knuckles brushed against my fingers.

We both yanked our hands back.

The pause stretched. The quiet in the empty restaurant suddenly felt heavy, thick with a heat that had absolutely no business existing between us.

"Daytime meetings from now on," I told him, breaking the silence. "Public coffee shops."

"Agreed," Ben said instantly. He picked up the two untouched sodas and poured them straight down the bar sink.

The tension followed me into the next afternoon at the academy's annual fundraiser. Parents crowded the gymnasium, bidding on silent auction items. I walked toward the VIP tables, stopping dead at the sight of the assigned seating.

Paige had placed her own name card next to Scott's at the center of the table. My name and Ben's name sat at the far opposite ends.

"The system auto-sorted by primary contact," Paige said, appearing behind me in a silk wrap.

I picked up the heavy cardstock. "You used my old photography client template. This is not an automated glitch."

Ava walked up to the table. She looked at the arrangement, picked up her mother's card, and flipped it face down on the tablecloth.

A few feet away, the event photographer raised his camera. "Smile, Morgan family!"

Chloe crossed her arms and stepped out of the frame, refusing to stand next to Scott.

"Do not make the girls pick sides," I told Paige. I flipped the card back up, restoring the arrangement.

Then I flagged down the event host walking past our table with a clipboard.

"Correct the parent introductions before you get on stage," I instructed the host, pointing at the four names. "Introduce us as four distinct households. Do not group the marriages together."

Paige's jaw tightened, but she kept her polite smile frozen in place.

The event photographer lowered his camera and walked over to me. "Hannah, I just emailed you the backend drive link for the event photos. You can pull whatever you need for the school newsletter."

I opened the email on my phone and clicked the shared link.

The folder loaded on my screen. Nestled between the auction headshots and the catering receipts was an old directory titled Family Transition.

The timestamp read twenty-two months ago.

I tapped the directory.

The first thumbnail to load was not a text document, but a set of colored floor plans dividing our four children into two future bedrooms.

My Husband Wanted My Best Friend, So I Chose Hers

Chapter 2 : Cecilia
Chapters
Customize
Next Chapter