Chapter 4

The cake was still on the kitchen floor when I got back.

Two days of it. Buttercream gone yellow at the edges, the sponge dried into something gray and crumbling. Nobody had touched it. Not the cleaning service — Keaton had canceled them last month to save money he didn't need to save. Not him.

He was on the couch when I came in. Laptop open, tie loose, a glass of scotch sweating on the coffee table without a coaster. He looked up.

"You're back."

That was it. That was the whole thing.

I stood in the doorway with my overnight bag in my hand and rain still in my hair. My shoulders were a map of purple under my sweater. I could feel every place the broom handle had landed when I breathed.

"You didn't move out," I said.

"Why would I move out?" He didn't even look up from the screen. "It's my apartment."

I'd picked the paint color for that living room. I'd waited four months for the sofa he was sitting on.

"Right," I said.

I went to the kitchen. I got the trash bag and the paper towels and I got down on my knees on the tile and I cleaned up my own birthday cake. It took twenty minutes. He never asked what happened. He never asked where I'd been for two days, or why I moved like something inside me had been rearranged.

He just typed.

---

That was how the next three weeks went.

He lived like a man who had misplaced a receipt and decided it wasn't worth the trouble of looking for it. He came and went. He took the elevator down one floor and came back up smelling like her perfume — something sharp and floral, expensive, nothing like the vanilla soap I'd used for seven years. Some nights he didn't come up at all until one, two in the morning. I'd hear the front door, then the shower, then nothing.

He never apologized. Not once. He never explained.

He corrected me, though. When I asked, once, if he planned to say anything about it, he set his fork down like I'd interrupted something important.

"You made it a spectacle, Cadence. His mother. Julian. Half the firm." He shook his head. "You want an apology from me? You blew up my life over a misunderstanding you refused to hear out."

"A misunderstanding."

"You've always done this." He picked the fork back up. "You build a story in your head and then you punish me for it."

I looked at his face and I waited for the anger. It didn't come. Something else came instead — a flat, cold curiosity, like watching a stranger perform a trick I'd already seen the mechanics of.

He was never going to apologize. Not because he was cruel. Because in his version, there was nothing to apologize for.

---

Yareli got louder.

She knew I'd looked. She knew exactly where I'd look again.

Monday: a video of Keaton at her stove, back to the camera, flipping something in a pan. His shoulders. His weekend sweater, the gray one I bought him in Maine. Caption: *he insists 🍳*

Wednesday: roses in a crystal vase on a windowsill, the same skyline out the glass, one floor lower than mine. *Morning person now 🌹*

Friday: a hand — hers — with a coffee cup, and in the corner of the frame, blurred but unmistakable, his watch on her nightstand.

Then the notification came.

**yareli.cruz wants to follow you.**

I sat on the edge of the bed and stared at it for a long time. My thumb hovered. Accept. Decline. Block.

She wanted me to look. That was the whole point. Every post was a hand on my throat and this was her asking permission to squeeze.

I put the phone face down and didn't answer it. I didn't decline either. I let the request sit there, unresolved, the way everything in my life was sitting unresolved, and I hated myself a little for not being able to do even that much.

The worst part wasn't the posts.

The worst part was the floor.

Our bedroom sat directly over hers. Some nights, when the building went quiet and the traffic on the avenue thinned out, I could hear her laughing. Not words. Just the shape of it — bright, easy, spilling up through the hardwood like water finding a crack. A woman laughing in a room I paid for with seven years of my life.

I lay there with my hand flat against the mattress and I listened to the sound of my replacement being happy underneath me.

---

The email about the Hamptons retreat came on a Tuesday. Sent to the whole firm, and to me, because I'd been on the partner-spouse list since year two.

*Howard & Vance Annual Retreat. Southampton. Cocktails Friday, dinner Saturday. Partners and guests.*

Guests.

Keaton mentioned it once, in passing, buttoning his cuff in front of the mirror.

"Eleanor Croft's coming Saturday. Wear the green dress."

Not *will you come.* Not *are you okay to come.* The green dress. The one that photographed well.

I should have said no. I know that now.

But I hadn't found it yet — the thread. The one loose piece you pull to make the whole thing come apart. I was still living in the wreckage, still moving through the apartment like a caretaker in a house nobody lived in anymore, and some hollowed-out part of me thought that if I just kept performing, the ground would stop shifting.

So I packed the green dress.

---

We drove out Friday afternoon. Two hours on the Montauk Highway, the sun laying itself down flat and gold across the potato fields, the hedgerows going by in long green blurs.

Keaton was on the phone the entire time.

Julian Vance, from the sound of it. Something about the Croft term sheet, then something about a boat, then something that made Keaton throw his head back and laugh — really laugh, loud and open, the laugh I used to work so hard for.

He held the wheel with two fingers. He said *buddy* eleven times. I counted.

He did not say one word to me. Not one. Not *are you cold,* not *do you want to stop,* not *hand me the water.* For two hours I sat eighteen inches from a man I'd loved for seven years and I was furniture. I was the passenger seat.

I watched the hedges go past and thought about how strange it was that I'd stopped expecting anything at all.

At some point he pulled into the drive of the estate — white gravel, boxwood, a caterer's van idling by the service entrance. He killed the engine and finally turned to me, phone still glowing in his hand.

"Yareli's coming Saturday," he said. "She's an associate now. It'd look worse if she wasn't here."

He was already opening his door.

"Don't make it weird."

Behind the house, past the tennis court, someone had planted roses along the whole length of the garden wall. Rows of them, deep red, blooming hard in the last of the light.

I looked at them for a long moment before I got out of the car.

Chapter 5

The Hamptons estate was the kind of place that appeared in magazines with words like *timeless* and *understated elegance*. White gravel drives. Boxwood hedges trimmed into perfect geometry. A tennis court nobody used and a catering tent strung with Edison bulbs that glowed soft and gold as the sun dropped behind the dunes.

I stood on the terrace with a gin and tonic I hadn't asked for, watching the firm's junior associates cluster near the bar like birds at a feeder. Keaton was across the lawn with Julian and two men in navy blazers, all of them laughing at something on Julian's phone.

He hadn't looked at me since we arrived.

I'd worn the green dress. I'd done my hair. I'd smiled at Eleanor Croft and complimented her earrings and asked about her daughter's gallery opening in Tribeca. I had performed every single expected beat, and Keaton had walked past me twice without a word.

Then Yareli arrived.

She came through the French doors in a white linen dress that probably cost more than my first car, her hair pulled back in a low ponytail, gold hoops catching the light. She looked like someone who summered. Someone who belonged.

She made a straight line for Keaton.

I watched her cross the terrace. I watched her touch his arm — just a light brush, nothing you could call inappropriate if you were only half paying attention. I watched him turn, smile, lean in to hear whatever she was saying. His hand went to the small of her back. Just for a second. Just long enough.

Then she turned and looked directly at me.

She smiled.

She walked over, heels clicking on the flagstone, and stopped two feet away. Up close I could see the fine gold chain at her throat, the perfect manicure, the faint shimmer of highlighter along her cheekbones.

"Cadence! Hi!" Her voice was bright, warm, like we were old friends. "You look tired. It must be so hard keeping up with everything."

She tilted her head, eyes wide with concern that didn't reach past her pupils.

I looked at her and said nothing.

She waited, smile fixed in place, and when I didn't answer she laughed — light, breezy, already turning away. "Well, I should go say hi to Eleanor. See you at dinner!"

She walked off.

Keaton had watched the whole thing. He'd been standing right there, ten feet away, glass in hand.

He turned back to Julian without a word.

---

I needed air. Or another drink. Or both.

I walked down the terrace steps toward the garden, where the caterers had set up a second bar near the rose wall. The roses were in full bloom, deep red and heavy-headed, planted in a long hedge that ran the length of the property line. They smelled like funerals.

I picked up two glasses of champagne from a passing tray — one for me, one for my hands to hold so they'd stop shaking.

I was halfway back to the terrace when I heard her voice behind me.

"Oh — excuse me—"

I turned.

Yareli was right there, too close, stepping directly into my path with a bright, startled expression. Her heel caught — or seemed to catch — on the edge of the flagstone.

She stumbled forward.

Her hands came up and hit my shoulders, hard, and I went sideways, off balance, champagne glasses flying, and then I was falling into the hedge.

I hit the roses full-body.

Thorns tore into my arms, my neck, the side of my face. I felt them punch through the thin fabric of my dress and drag down my ribs, my thighs, catching and ripping as I tried to pull myself upright. My hands sank into the branches and more thorns went into my palms, sharp and deep.

I heard someone gasp.

I pulled myself out, thorns still embedded in my skin, blood already welling up in thin red lines across my forearms. I could feel them in my neck. In my collarbone. In the soft skin behind my ear.

Yareli's hand flew to her mouth.

"Oh my God!" Her voice was high, horrified, loud enough to carry. "Are you okay? I'm so clumsy, I'm so sorry!"

People were staring now. Eleanor Croft. Julian. A woman in pearls I didn't recognize.

And Keaton.

He was three feet away, glass still in his hand, looking at me.

I stood there bleeding, thorns still in my arms, my dress torn at the shoulder, and I waited.

He looked at me.

Then he crouched down next to Yareli.

"Are you alright?" His voice was low, concerned. He took her elbow, steadying her. "Did you twist your ankle?"

She shook her head, eyes wide. "I'm fine, I just — I feel terrible, I didn't see her—"

"It's okay." He was still holding her arm. "Let me see your shoes. Are they scuffed?"

He tilted her foot, checking the heel.

I stood there.

Blood ran down my wrist and dripped onto the flagstone.

He did not look at me.

Not once.

Someone — one of the caterers, maybe, or a junior associate whose name I didn't know — came over with a stack of cocktail napkins and pressed them into my hand. "Ma'am, do you need—"

"I'm fine," I said.

My voice sounded far away.

I turned and walked back toward the house, thorns still in my skin, blood soaking through the napkins, and nobody followed me.

---

I sat on the edge of the bathtub in my guest room and pulled the thorns out one by one.

There were forty-three of them. I counted.

Some came out clean. Some broke off under the skin and I had to dig for them with the hotel tweezers, the points so small I could barely see them. My hands shook. The antiseptic stung. The cotton balls I used turned red, one after another, a small pile of them growing on the counter beside me.

I thought about my mother standing in the rain with a broom in her hand.

I thought about the cake on the floor and Keaton stepping over it without looking back.

I thought about him crouching beside Yareli, checking her shoes, while I stood there bleeding three feet away.

Seven years.

I'd given him seven years.

I pulled the last thorn from my forearm and dropped it in the trash.

Then I picked up my phone and called Daisy.

She answered on the second ring. "Cade?"

"I need to leave," I said.

And then I told her everything.

I talked for forty minutes. The roses. The apartment. The hospital. The broom. The thorns. I didn't cry. I just spoke, steady and flat, like I was reading a list.

When I finally stopped, the silence on the other end stretched long enough that I thought the call had dropped.

Then Daisy's voice came through, quiet and absolutely certain.

"I'm booking you a one-way ticket to Heathrow. There's a bedroom here with your name on it and a desk at my agency. You just have to get to JFK."

I looked at my reflection in the mirror. At the cuts on my neck. At the woman staring back at me with blood on her hands and something new in her eyes.

"I will," I said. "But first I have something to do."

"I know," Daisy said. "Make it count."

I hung up.

I sat there on the edge of the tub for a long time, looking at the thorns in the trash and the blood on the cotton and the long red lines across my skin that would scar.

Then I opened my laptop.

Unlock Now
Show your support to inspire the writer to come up with more fantastic stories

My Husband Bought His Mistress Our Downstairs Apartment

Chapter 4 : Avery Knox
Chapters
Customize
Next Chapter