Dr. Morrow's office was warm. Too warm. I sat in the chair by the window and watched the January sleet tap against the glass.

"You've been quiet today," Diana said.

I didn't answer right away. I was thinking about the letter Raphael had slipped under my office door yesterday. The fourth one. I'd burned it in my kitchen sink without reading it.

"He's getting desperate," I said finally.

Diana waited. She was good at waiting.

"He keeps asking to talk. Keeps saying he needs to explain." I turned away from the window. "He thinks this is about the affair. About the divorce. He thinks if he apologizes enough, if he performs enough regret, I'll eventually let him back in."

"And you're not ready to correct him."

I looked at her. "No."

"Why?"

The question sat between us. I could feel my pulse in my throat.

"Because I need Karsyn in the room first," I said. "If I show him now, she runs. And I will not let her run."

Diana nodded slowly. "That's the practical reason."

I looked back at the window. The sleet was coming down harder now.

"What's the other reason?" Diana asked.

I didn't speak for a long time. My hands were folded in my lap, fingers laced tight.

"I'm afraid," I said finally.

Diana's voice was gentle. "Of what?"

I closed my eyes. "Of how I'll feel when I watch it break him."

Silence.

"I don't hate him because he left me," I said. My voice was steady. Careful. "I hate him because my father died in a prison cell still believing Raphael would come back and save him. Dad wrote him letters. Did you know that? Three of them. I found them in his things. He never sent them. He kept waiting. Kept thinking Raphael was just busy. That he'd come."

My throat was tight. I made it loosen.

"And Raphael was in London," I continued. "Living his life. Building his career. Sleeping next to the woman who murdered my father and calling it love."

I opened my eyes. Stared at the sleet.

"So no," I said quietly. "I'm not ready. Because when I finally show him what he did, when I make him see it—really see it—I'm afraid some part of me will still want to catch him when he falls. And I can't let that happen."

Diana was quiet for a moment.

"You're allowed to grieve what he used to be," she said.

I looked at her. "I can't afford to."

"Sloane—"

"If I grieve him, I forgive him," I said. "And forgiveness is not something I have to give."

Diana studied my face. Then she nodded.

I left her office twenty minutes later. My hands were steady when I pushed through the door into the cold.

---

Raphael called my cell phone at eleven that night.

I was in bed, reading case law on my tablet. When his name lit up the screen, I stared at it until it stopped ringing.

He called again at eleven-fifteen.

Again at eleven-thirty.

I turned my phone off and went to sleep.

---

The next morning, Bodhi knocked on my office door at seven-fifteen.

"Gordon's been making calls," Bodhi said.

I looked up from my coffee. "What kind of calls?"

"Asking about Colten. Where he is. Why he's not listed in the alumni directory anymore." Bodhi's face was hard. "He called Jim Kellerman yesterday. You remember Jim? Clerked for your dad in 2018."

"What did Jim say?"

"Nothing. Hung up on him." Bodhi crossed his arms. "But Gordon's not stupid, Sloane. He's going to figure it out."

I set down my coffee. "Let him."

Bodhi stared at me. "You sure?"

I nodded slowly. "I'm sure."

Bodhi left.

I sat at my desk and opened my bottom drawer. The manila folder was right where it always was. I pulled it out and set it on my desk.

Then I picked up my phone and texted Margaret.

*Pull every news item published about Colten Richardson between 2019 and 2020. Send me the links.*

Her reply came two minutes later: *On it.*

I leaned back in my chair and stared at the ceiling.

Raphael was finally asking the right questions.

Five years too late.

---

Margaret's email arrived at noon. Seventeen links. Most of them were buried in legal trade publications. Obituaries. Bar association notices.

One was different.

A brief news item from March 2019. Two paragraphs. Dry. Factual.

*Colten Richardson, former senior partner at Richardson & Hale, passed away in custody following his 2019 conviction on financial fraud charges. He was 61. Richardson, who spent over thirty years in practice and was known for his pro bono work in wrongful conviction cases, is survived by his daughter, Sloane Richardson.*

I read it three times.

Then I forwarded the email to Bodhi with a single line: *He's going to find this.*

Bodhi's reply was immediate: *Good.*

I closed my laptop.

My phone buzzed. Raphael's name on the screen.

I let it ring.

Then I stood, grabbed my coat, and walked out of the office into the cold January afternoon.

I didn't know where I was going. I just walked.

By the time I stopped, I was standing outside the courthouse where my father used to try cases.

I looked up at the stone columns. The wide steps. The building where he'd spent thirty years fighting for people who had nothing.

My phone buzzed again.

I pulled it out. Raphael. Again.

I stared at his name on the screen.

Then I answered.

"What," I said.

Silence. Then his voice, low and shaking.

"Sloane. I need to see you. Right now."

I closed my eyes. "No."

"Please. I just—" His voice broke. "I need to ask you something. Just one question. Please."

I stood there on the courthouse steps, holding the phone, feeling the cold wind cut through my coat.

"You had five years to ask questions, Raphael," I said quietly.

I hung up.

Then I turned off my phone, walked down the steps, and went home.