Chapter 5
Ethan’s brow furrowed even deeper. He had to hand it to her—Cora was a master at getting under his skin. But this? Going so far as to find another man just to piss him off? That was beyond anything he’d expected. He couldn’t for the life of him figure out what she was trying to prove.
He pressed two fingers to his temple, trying to keep a lid on the anger climbing up his throat, then caught her by the wrist. “You’re coming back with me. Right now. You’re going to apologize to Lilah.”
“No, I’m not.”
Just then, Ethan’s phone buzzed. Cora’s gaze flicked down—Lilah’s name lit up the screen—and she used the distraction to yank her wrist free.
Ethan answered. A woman’s sobs spilled through the speaker. “Ethan, please come back. My leg hurts so much. I need you here—Ethan, please…”
Cora watched him, waiting for the choice she already knew he’d make. Sure enough, Ethan stared at her for a beat, then looked away. “Cora, you’d better think long and hard about what you did today.”
Then he turned and walked off without a moment’s hesitation, leaving Cora alone under the streetlight.
A few feet away, Joey Stevens had been leaning against a tree, taking it all in. Now he strolled over, a teasing smirk on his face, and dropped a bouquet of sunflowers at her feet. “Tough break, huh?”
He stepped closer, letting his lazy gaze drift over her face. His thumb brushed her tear-streaked cheek. “Crying again?”
Cora turned her head. “Who’s crying?”
She wasn’t crying over Ethan. She was crying over her own blindness for the past five years.
Joey let out a low chuckle.
The princess—delicate, vivid—looked like some fragile bloom raised in a greenhouse. But corner her, and she turned fierce and untamed, all claws and life.
Joey held out the sunflowers. “Don’t be sad. Your hubby’s here to cheer you up.”
Cora blinked. “How did you know I like sunflowers?”
Joey shrugged, all careless ease. “Lucky guess. They were the last bunch in the shop.”
When she glanced past him, she noticed he’d bought a few other things, too. Her guard slipped a little, and she managed a quiet “Thank you.”
Joey smiled, soft and slow, murmuring the words too low for her to catch. “You’re welcome, Mrs. Stevens.”
Cora spent the night at Joey’s villa. The next morning, she got up early to head back to Ethan’s family home.
Her luggage, packed the day before, was still in the living room. Before leaving, she’d confirmed Ethan was at the hospital with Lilah—just enough reassurance to walk in without hesitating.
What she didn’t expect was to find other familiar faces the moment she stepped into the living room.
Ethan’s parents. And his younger brother, Adrian.
Adrian was bent over her suitcase, rummaging through it like it belonged to him.
The instant he saw Cora, Ethan’s father’s face went hard with rage. He crossed the room and slapped her across the face.
“Have you lost your mind? Hiring someone to commit murder—what kind of insane stunt is that?”
The slap whipped Cora’s face to one side, leaving her ears ringing for a second.
Ethan’s parents had taken her in when she was fifteen. They’d always wanted a daughter, and Cora had filled that space—loved, spoiled, doted on without end. Then Ethan met Lilah, and everything changed.
Lilah came from one of the most prestigious families in the northern part of the city. She visited their home often, all soft manners and gentle smiles, and quickly charmed both parents. Soon their affection was split between Cora and Lilah.
Then, out of nowhere, Ethan’s parents turned cold toward Cora. It happened so fast that she still couldn’t understand what she’d done wrong.
They called her ungrateful. A monster. They wanted her out of the house. And after Ethan insisted on marrying her, the rift between Cora and his parents split wide open.
Her cheek stinging, Cora turned back to Ethan’s father. She said nothing. She took the pain without striking back, just watching him quietly.
They had raised her into adulthood, so she accepted the slap. But it cut whatever tie she still had with them. From that moment on, Cora was done with Ethan’s family.
Her mind flicked back to Ethan’s accusation about hiring someone to hurt Lilah.
Was it the driver who’d said it? Or Lilah herself? Or maybe Lilah had told the driver exactly what to say?
“What gives you the right to go through my suitcase?” Cora turned to Adrian.
Her eyes were dark. When she smiled, she looked sweet enough to trust. When she didn’t, her stare went cold and unsettling. Under it, Adrian shifted, suddenly uneasy for no reason he could name.
“I’m checking to see if you’ve hidden any other weapons!” he shouted. “What if you’re planning to hurt Lilah again?”
Ethan’s father caught sight of the red handprint blooming on her cheek, and a flicker of regret went through him. After all, he’d helped raise her.
Then Adrian spoke, and the anger surged back. “If you hadn’t pushed Lilah down the stairs, she wouldn’t be hurt.”
“Are you saying that, injured as she was, Lilah arranged her own hit just to frame me?”
Cora’s voice was cool. “Is that really so far-fetched?”
“How could we have raised such a vicious girl?”
Ethan’s parents were always like this—quick to condemn without knowing the whole story. She knew they adored Lilah: first as the daughter they’d wanted, then as the daughter-in-law they preferred.
Lilah was gentle. Kind. Born to privilege and tradition. Cora, by contrast, was always seen as untamed, wild, unpredictable—a lioness with no manners. So Lilah was always in the right.
“Mr. Connor? Mrs. Connor? You came to see me?” A voice cut through the tension.
Cora turned. Lilah stood there, her leg wrapped in thick bandages, looking frail as she leaned almost entirely into Ethan’s arms.
Ethan was holding her up.
Cora met his eyes.
Ethan noticed the handprint on Cora’s face at once. His brows drew together, and for a second he wanted to let go of Lilah and go check on Cora. Then he remembered it was his father who’d done it, and he stopped himself.
Still, somewhere inside, he blamed his father for hitting her too hard.
Ethan’s mother hurried over and took Lilah from him. “Why aren’t you resting at the hospital?”
“Mr. and Mrs. Connor, what’s going on?” Lilah asked weakly, rubbing her temples.
Ethan’s mother lowered her voice, soothing. “It’s nothing, really. It’s about Cora. We’re just giving her a little talk, hoping she’ll apologize to you.”
“An apology?” Lilah’s gaze drifted to Cora, as if she were only now noticing her. Tears welled in her eyes. “It’s okay. There’s no need. I believe Cora didn’t mean it.”
“We’ve always been good friends. Cora would never do such a thing. This needs to be looked into further.”
Ethan’s parents exchanged a look, visibly moved by Lilah’s understanding. If anything, it made her seem even more precious.
Ethan’s mother shot Cora a glare. “Look at yourself. Then look at Lilah.”
A lump swelled in Cora’s throat. Every time she and Lilah disagreed, Lilah played the patient peacemaker—patting Cora’s head, saying she didn’t mind, that it was fine.
And somehow, even when Cora had done nothing wrong, next to Lilah she looked guilty of something unforgivable.
“Lilah, stop being so nice!” Adrian cut in. “Cora’s the one who pushed you down the stairs!”
Chapter 6
Lilah Carter blinked up at them, eyes glassy with unshed tears. "I just don't understand why Cora would do something like this," she murmured. "I'm sure she didn't mean it..."
Edward Connor had a temper, and it flared the moment he saw no remorse on Cora Bennett's face. He grabbed her roughly. "Why are you just standing there? Apologize to Lilah—beg for her forgiveness!"
In his haste, he accidentally shoved Cora into the corner of a cabinet. She winced as pain shot through her. Pulling free, she walked straight to the couch—and, without a word, slapped Lilah hard across the cheek.
Once, she could let slide. Twice? Unforgivable. She might overlook Edward, but Lilah was a different story.
Lilah's scream split the air.
Edward froze. "Are you out of your mind?"
He raised his hand to strike back, but Ethan Connor caught his wrist and held it tight.
"That's enough," Ethan said, voice cool.
"Why are you taking her side?" Adrian, the younger brother, demanded in disbelief.
Every eye in the room swung to Ethan.
He stood beside Cora and said nothing.
Cora's voice was steady. "There's a hidden camera in the plant by the staircase. I'll pull up the footage now."
She'd installed it a while back to keep an eye on Whiskers, her cat.
Ethan caught her hand. He'd looked into the incident the night before and knew Cora wasn't to blame. Releasing the footage would only humiliate the family further.
Cora ignored him, pulled out her phone, and cast the footage to the living-room screen.
The video made it plain: Cora hadn't laid a hand on Lilah. Lilah had backed away and fallen all on her own—Cora had even reached out to help her before she went down. The footage froze on the moment Lilah hit the floor, revealing scratches on her leg left by her own manicure.
Silence swallowed the room.
Edward and his wife exchanged a look, suddenly understanding why Ethan had stepped in.
Ethan spoke up. "Let's take this one thing at a time. Cora is not responsible for what happened on the staircase."
Even with the evidence staring him in the face, Adrian insisted, "Fine—even if that was an accident, how do you explain the hit-and-run?"
Adrian clung stubbornly to his pride. "It's a good thing Lilah wasn't hurt. If she had been, Cora would be guilty."
Cora scoffed. Some people just refused to see reason.
She dialed 911. "I'll report it and let the police investigate."
At the word police, Lilah panicked. "It's okay, Cora. I know you didn't do it. Let's just forget it..."
Edward frowned. Would a guilty person really be this eager to call the police on herself?
Edward hesitated. "Do you really think this clears your name? Apologize to Lilah. Now—"
"Hello, 911," Cora said into the phone, cutting him off. "I'm being accused of a hit-and-run with intent to harm. The address is an estate in the Hamptons. Please come and arrest me."
A stunned silence fell over the room. Even Lilah forgot to keep up her expression.
After a beat, she covered her face with both hands, tears springing to her eyes. "Mr. and Mrs. Connor... it hurts..."
Edward let out a heavy sigh and went to comfort Lilah, making her the center of attention all over again—even after Cora had just called the police.
Soon enough, the family found themselves back at the police station. The officer on duty—the same rookie from the night before—was stunned to see Cora again so soon. He hadn't forgotten how respectfully the chief had treated her.
"Officer, this woman hired someone to hurt Lilah!" Adrian's voice cut through the room as he jabbed a finger at Cora, his glare sharp as a blade.
The officer hesitated, then turned to Edward and his wife. "Is this young woman your daughter?" He gestured at Lilah, who was leaning weakly against Ethan.
Edward and his wife hesitated, visibly uncomfortable. For years, they had introduced Cora as part of their family. Yet Adrian had just rushed to defend Lilah, while they treated the girl they had raised like an enemy. Only now did they seem to notice.
Edward's wife shifted uncomfortably and pointed at Cora. "No—she's my daughter."
The rookie's face twisted in disbelief.
He asked a few clarifying questions, and the full picture became clear. His expression turned contemptuous; he glanced at Cora with sympathy. Since walking into the station, she'd been as calm as she had been the night before—a stark contrast to her loud, chaotic family.
If he didn't know better, he'd have thought she and Edward were enemies, not father and daughter.
Especially with Ethan—tall, handsome, engaged to Cora, and yet letting another woman lean on him. It was just plain unfair.
The rookie officer stood, frowning. "Wait here. I'll get the chief."
The chief? Was this really that serious?
Adrian burst out laughing. "You just made a very expensive mistake, Cora. Once the chief gets here, you'll be counting the years you spend in jail!"
They'd heard of the old chief—a man who acted fast and judged hard. If he got involved, jail time was inevitable.
Even Lilah looked surprised by how serious it had become, though she quickly hid it behind a sly little smile.
It didn't matter. She'd prepared thoroughly.
Her eyes welled with tears as she clung to Edward and his wife's hands. "Please, Mr. and Mrs. Connor, let's drop this. If they find something, Cora could go to prison. She's my only good friend..."
Her tearful act softened Edward's wife, who wanted to comfort her. Still, the thought of Cora in prison left a bitter taste in her mouth.
Even Ethan looked shaken. He hadn't meant for things to spiral this far. He walked over to Cora.
He lowered his eyes and folded her hand in his, trying to lead her away. "Cora, maybe we should—"
She pulled her hand back, frowning, and refused to say a word.
Talking to them any longer felt like a waste of breath.
Edward stepped forward, thoughtful. "Cora, just apologize to Lilah, and we can put this behind us."
After all, Cora had been raised like a beloved daughter. He couldn't quite bear the thought of her suffering in prison.
But Cora's laugh was cold. "Apologize? Maybe once I'm six feet under. Aren't you all eager to see me behind bars? I can apologize from jail."
"That's what you really want, isn't it?"
"You—!" Edward sputtered, furious. "You'll regret this!"