Chapter 1

The first call I made after the crash went to my husband.

He texted, "I'm in a meeting."

But I found him holding another woman's hand.

...

Rush hour on the FDR had turned into a wall of metal.

One truck slammed into my back bumper. Another swallowed my front end. My little sedan folded between them like paper.

Glass split my forehead. The door crushed my left leg. My right arm caught the edge of the dashboard, and something inside it screamed.

A paramedic pried me out. "Ma'am, can you hear me? What's your name?"

"Evelyn," I managed. "Evelyn Vale."

"Will anyone pick you up?"

"My husband. I'll call him."

The phone rang four times, then went silent. Then came the text.

I'm in a meeting.

Somewhere behind us, another ambulance wailed. A woman's voice carried through its open doors, thin and shaking.

"Please don't leave me! Nobody's coming for me!"

The paramedic snorted. "That one's got a scraped elbow. She's been crying like that for a while."

I didn't laugh. I didn't have the strength.

...

Mount Sinai's ER smelled like bleach. Every chair was taken. A man bled into a towel beside the vending machine. A toddler wailed on his mother's hip.

A nurse pushed an IV bag into my good hand. "Hold this up. Registration's on the left. We're slammed tonight."

"I can barely walk."

"I know, honey. Everybody here can barely do something."

So I limped. I hugged the bag against my chest and pressed my sleeve to my forehead. My leg throbbed with every step.

The clerk at the window didn't look up. "Insurance card?"

"In my wallet. I need a second."

"Take your time." She glanced at the line behind me. "But not too much."

X-ray. CT scan. A tech who called me "sweetheart" and jabbed my arm twice before finding a vein. Then the payment kiosk, where I fumbled my card with shaking fingers while blood dripped onto the screen.

I called Adrian again.

Straight to voicemail.

I texted. I was in a car accident. I'm at Mount Sinai. Please come.

Three dots appeared. Vanished. Appeared again.

Still in the meeting. Handle it, Evie. You're capable.

I stared at that text.

...

They sent me down the east hallway to wait for stitches. The curtains there were half open, and I heard a man's voice I knew better than my own.

"Slowly. It's hot."

I stopped walking.

Through the gap, I saw him. Adrian. Charcoal suit, tie loosened, sleeves rolled to the elbow. He sat on the edge of a hospital bed, peeling an apple in one long, careful ribbon.

The woman in the bed had a single bandage on her elbow.

Serena Whitmore. His college classmate. The one he never talked about, until she moved back to Manhattan three months ago.

He set the apple down and poured her a cup of water. He tucked a strand of hair behind her ear.

"You're safe now," he murmured. "I'm right here."

My IV bag slipped an inch in my grip.

Serena's eyes found mine first. They went wide. Then wet. Instantly, perfectly wet.

"Adrian," she whispered. "Your wife is here."

He turned. For one second, his face went blank.

Serena pulled her hand from his and pressed it to her chest. "You should go. Please. I don't want to cause trouble between you two. I'll be fine alone. I'm used to it."

"Serena, stop," he said softly.

I stepped inside the curtain. My leg nearly buckled.

"I called you," I said. "Three times."

Adrian rose. His gaze slid over me. Something flickered in his jaw, then settled.

"I was in a meeting."

"Here? In the ER?"

"Before. It ran late." He spread his hands. "Then Serena called. She has no family in the city, Evie. What was I supposed to do, ignore her?"

"You ignored me."

"You texted that you were handling it."

"I texted that I was in a car accident."

"And you're standing. You're talking." He gestured at me like I was proof of something. "You're fine."

I laughed. It came out of nowhere, sharp and ugly, and it made Serena flinch.

"Fine," I repeated. "I carried my own IV bag through registration. I paid my own bill with blood on my hands. And you were here. Peeling apples."

"She's an old friend."

Serena's lower lip trembled. "Evelyn, please. I know how this looks. But nothing is going on between us. Nothing." She dabbed her eyes with the sheet. "I just didn't expect you to follow him all the way here."

The room went still.

"Follow him?" I said.

"I only mean..." She glanced at Adrian, then back at me, voice tiny. "How else would you know which room?"

"I was in the same crash."

Adrian's brow creased. "What?"

"The FDR pileup. We were both in it." I tilted my head at Serena. "I heard you in the ambulance. Crying that nobody would come."

Serena's mouth opened. Closed.

Adrian didn't ask if I was badly hurt. He just rubbed the bridge of his nose, like I was a headache he had scheduled for later.

"Evelyn, this isn't the place."

"You're right." I set the IV bag on the tray beside Serena's apple. My hand had gone strangely steady. "So I'll keep it short. I want a divorce."

A nurse behind the next curtain stopped moving. A patient across the hall lowered his phone.

Adrian stared at me. Then his voice rose, loud and clean, built for an audience.

"Do you hear yourself? You accuse me of cheating with a friend who's been through hell, and now you want a divorce? Over an apple?"

"Over three missed calls."

"Over your paranoia." He stepped closer. Cologne and antiseptic. "You've been suspicious for months. Checking my phone. Asking where I am. This is that, Evie. This is you losing it."

"Everyone here can see what you're doing." He swept a hand toward the hallway, toward the strangers watching. "Making a scene in a hospital. Humiliating me."

Serena reached for his sleeve. "Adrian, don't. She's hurt. She doesn't mean it."

"Oh, she means it. Right up until she remembers what she'd be walking away from." His lip curled. "The penthouse. The cards. The name. You think anyone would look twice at you without the Vale behind it?"

Heat rushed into my face. My forehead started aching again.

"Is that what you think I'm afraid of?"

"I know it is." He adjusted his cuff, and the gold band on his finger caught the light. Our wedding ring. "Go get stitched up. Go home. We'll talk when you're rational."

He turned back to the bed.

Serena watched me over his shoulder. The tears were gone. Her lips curved, just slightly.

Chapter 2

The nurse never came back to stitch me up.

I sat on a plastic chair for forty minutes, watching the hallway clock. Then I peeled the tape off the back of my hand and pulled the IV line out.

A bead of blood swelled up. I pressed my thumb on it.

"Ma'am?" A young orderly stopped his cart. "You can't just leave. You haven't been discharged."

"Then bill my husband," I said. "He's in room nine, peeling apples."

Outside, the cold hit my face like a slap. I dug through my bag for my keys before I remembered. My car was a folded tin can on the FDR.

Fine. I would take a cab to the penthouse, grab the spare SUV from the garage, and drive myself somewhere quiet.

The cab pulled up. I slid in, and my leg screamed.

"Where to?"

"Fifty-Seventh and Park."

The driver pulled into traffic. Two blocks later, my stomach rolled. My mouth filled with spit. I pictured the bedroom that still smelled like Adrian's cologne.

I pictured him walking in at midnight, telling me to be rational.

"Change of plans," I said. "Take me to Carroll Gardens. Brooklyn."

The driver glanced in the mirror. "You okay, lady? You're kinda gray."

"I'm capable," I said, and laughed until it turned into a cough.

...

Nora Bell opened her door in sweatpants and a face mask. The mask cracked when her mouth fell open.

"Evie. Oh my God. Is that blood? Is that *your* blood?"

She yanked me inside and pushed me down onto her couch. Her cat bolted under the radiator.

"Don't move." She ran for the bathroom and came back with a first-aid kit the size of a toolbox. "What happened? Who did this? Do I need a shovel?"

"Car accident. FDR."

"And you came *here*? Not home?" She soaked a cotton pad and dabbed my forehead. I winced. "Sorry, sorry. Hold still. Where's Adrian?"

I didn't answer.

Nora stopped dabbing. "Evelyn. Where is your husband?"

"With Serena." I stared at her bookshelf.

"Serena. College Serena?"

"She had a scraped elbow."

The cotton pad hit the coffee table with a wet slap.

"He *left* you for a scraped elbow?"

"He didn't leave me. He just didn't come." I held out my right arm. The emergency bandage had slipped and soaked through. "He was in a meeting. Then he wasn't."

Nora unwound the old gauze with tight, angry fingers. She muttered the whole time.

"That smug, cuff-linked, golf-playing piece of garbage. I'm going to key his Porsche. I'm going to put shrimp in his air vents."

"He said I was paranoid." My voice came out flat. "In the hallway. Loud. He said nobody would look twice at me without the Vale name."

Her hands froze on my arm.

"He said I'd come back. Because of the penthouse. The cards."

Nora wrapped fresh gauze around my forearm, slower now. Careful.

"Evie, you were a senior strategist at Halbrook. You had a corner office before you were thirty."

"I know."

"You quit."

"Because somebody had to run the house and the dinners and the charity boards." My throat closed up. I forced the words through anyway. "I learned how he likes his coffee. Which client hates shellfish. Which tie he wears when he's nervous. I never touched his money, Nora. I never even wanted the ring that big."

She taped the gauze down without a word.

"I married him because I loved him," I said. "That's it. That's the whole stupid reason."

Nora sat back on her heels. Her eyes were wet, but her voice came out hard.

"I know that. I've always known that." She took a breath. "But he doesn't, babe. He never did."

"What do you mean?"

"Your wedding. The reception. I went out for air and heard him on the terrace with his groomsmen." She looked away. "One of them joked that you hit the jackpot. And Adrian said, 'Everybody's got a price. At least hers is pretty.'"

The room went very quiet. Even the radiator stopped hissing.

"You never told me that."

"You were glowing. You were so happy." Nora gripped my good hand. "I thought he'd grow out of it. I was wrong. Divorce him, Evie. Fast. Before he figures out how to make you the villain."

I looked down at my wedding band. It had a smear of dried blood on it.

"Tomorrow," I said. "I'm finding a job."

"Tomorrow you're resting."

"Tomorrow I'm finding a job. I'm done being something he pays for."

...

Lark & Pruitt Brand Group sat on the forty-first floor of a glass tower in Hudson Yards. I wore Nora's blazer over my bandaged arm and swept my bangs over the stitches the urgent care clinic had finally given me that morning.

The interviewer, Dana Okafor, flipped through my portfolio twice.

"You built the Halbrook luxury rebrand?"

"I led it."

"That campaign is still taught in grad school." She closed the folder and smiled. "Your career gap doesn't bother me. Honestly, I'd hire you today. I just need Martin to sign off. Can you wait in the hall?"

"Of course."

I sat on a leather bench outside the CEO's office. My leg ached. My heart was racing anyway, the good kind of racing. The kind I hadn't felt in four years.

Martin Kessler's door was open a crack. His phone was on speaker.

"Adrian! Good to hear from you. How's the Hartley thing?"

My spine went rigid.

"Closing next week." My husband's voice. Smooth. Warm. "Listen, Martin, I need a favor. You've got that associate strategist role open?"

"We do. Actually, Dana's got a strong candidate right—"

"Hold it for me. I have someone. Serena Whitmore."

I gripped my résumé so hard the paper buckled.

"Serena... is she in branding?"

"She did some freelance. Instagram stuff." A soft laugh. "Look, she needs something light, something with good people around her. You'd be doing me a personal favor."

"What if I say no?"

"The Vale account renewal would go very smoothly."

A pause. Then Martin chuckled. "Tell her to come on Monday."

"You're a good friend, Martin."

I stood up. Dana was walking toward me down the hall, my file in her hand, her face already falling.

"Evelyn, I'm so sorry. Something's come up—"

"I heard."

"It's not about you. You're the most qualified person I've seen all year."

"I know," I said. "That's the funny part."

I dropped the crumpled résumé in the trash can by the elevator. The doors closed on her stunned face.

...

Nora was waiting with takeout when I got back to Brooklyn.

"Well? Corner office? Stock options?"

"Serena got it."

The chopsticks slipped out of her hand. "*What?*"

"He called the CEO while I was sitting outside the door. Said she needed the position to recover." I sank onto the couch. "He didn't even know I was there. He wasn't trying to hurt me. He just never thought about me at all."

Nora opened her mouth. Shut it. Then she grabbed a pillow and screamed into it.

My phone buzzed on the cushion.

Adrian.

Come home when you've calmed down.

I read it once. Then again. Five words, and not one of them was *are you hurt*.

"What does he want?" Nora asked, muffled by the pillow.

"Me. Calm. Quiet. Grateful."

I opened his contact. My thumb hovered over the screen.

Block this caller.

I pressed it.

The screen went still, and for the first time in two days, so did my hands.

Chapter 3

My mother answered the door before I could knock twice.

"Evelyn. What on earth happened to your face?"

"Car accident. I'm okay."

She stepped aside, her eyes already moving past me to the street. "Where's Adrian?"

"That's why I'm here."

My father sat in his leather chair in the den with the *Journal* folded across his knee. He didn't stand. He took in my bandaged arm, my limp, the bangs combed over my stitches.

"You look terrible," Richard Hart said. "Sit."

I stayed on my feet. My leg throbbed, but sitting felt like surrender.

"I'm divorcing Adrian."

The newspaper slid off his knee and hit the rug.

My mother laughed, a light, social laugh. The kind she used at charity galas when someone told a bad joke. "Don't be dramatic, sweetheart."

"He left me bleeding in the ER to hold Serena Whitmore's hand. Then he got her a job I was interviewing for."

"Serena who?" Mom asked.

"It doesn't matter who," Dad cut in. He rose at last, and his face had gone dark red. "Do you know what's on my desk right now? The Riverside development. Vale Group is carrying forty percent of the financing. Forty, Evelyn."

"I didn't ask about your project."

"You're about to blow it up." He jabbed a finger at the window, like the deal was parked outside. "Two years of work. And you want to throw it away because your husband visited a sick friend?"

"I had an accident but he was with another woman and didn't show up."

"And you survived."

Mom took my good hand and squeezed it, too hard. Her rings bit my knuckles.

"Listen to me. Men stray. Men get distracted. A smart wife doesn't make it a war. She makes him miss her." She tipped her chin up. "You go home tonight. Wear the green dress. Apologize for the scene at the hospital."

"Apologize. To him."

"Yes."

"Mom, he called me paranoid in front of strangers."

"Then don't give him reasons." Her voice dropped and went cold. "And understand this. If you walk out on that marriage, don't come running here. No a dime from this family."

I pulled my hand back. I'd thought I was done being hurt this week. I was wrong.

"Good to know where I stand."

The doorbell rang.

Mom's face lit up. "That'll be him. I called him the second I saw you on the porch."

...

Adrian walked in with his coat open and his jaw set hard. He kissed my mother's cheek. He shook my father's hand. Only then did he turn to me.

"You blocked my number. My wife vanishes from a hospital against medical advice, and I hear about it from an orderly." He shook his head. "You took a misunderstanding and turned it into a war, Evie."

"It's not a misunderstanding."

"Serena is a friend. She's alone in this city. Someone has to look out for her." He stepped aside. "And she wanted to see you. To fix this."

Serena drifted in from the hallway in a cream sweater. The bandage on her elbow looked fresh, almost decorative. Her eyes were already shining.

"Evelyn." Her voice wobbled. "I'm so, so sorry."

Nobody spoke. My father crossed his arms. My mother put on her hostess smile.

"I never wanted to hurt your marriage. Never." Serena twisted her fingers together. "After the crash, I just… I froze. I couldn't stop shaking. And I don't have anyone. My parents are gone. My brother doesn't speak to me. Adrian was the only one I knew in this city."

She looked up at him through wet lashes.

"I don't have a family to run to. Not like you do."

Adrian's throat moved. He reached out and touched her shoulder, and his whole body softened.

"You don't need to explain yourself to her," he said quietly.

"I do. She thinks I'm a monster."

Mom hissed my name. Serena turned away, shoulders trembling.

I picked up my bag. "I'm leaving."

...

I made it to the top of the staircase before I heard soft footsteps behind me.

"Evelyn, wait."

Serena held a glass of hot water she had brought from the kitchen. Steam curled off the top.

"You forgot to say goodbye," she said. The tremble had left her voice.

"Move."

"He'll never pick you. You know that, right?" She smiled. "He feels sorry for me. You, he just feels stuck with."

Then she tilted the glass.

Hot water spilled across her own wrist. Then she screamed.

"Adrian!"

He took the stairs at once. Serena collapsed against the railing, cradling her arm. The skin was already flushed an angry pink.

"She threw it at me," Serena sobbed. "I only wanted to talk. She threw it."

"I didn't touch her."

Adrian grabbed Serena's wrist and turned it toward the light. A muscle jumped in his cheek. When he looked up at me, I didn't recognize him.

"What is wrong with you?"

"She poured it on herself."

"Listen to yourself!" His voice cracked through the house. "You're out of control. You're insane, and now you're hurting her. This has to stop."

He pulled out his phone. "Gordon. Bring the papers to the Hart house. Now."

...

Gordon Pike arrived within the hour, briefcase already packed. He laid the agreement on my father's desk like a dinner menu.

I flipped through it. Then flipped again, slower.

"Four years, and I leave with my clothes." My fingers left a smudge on the page.

"You left with my respect a long time ago," Adrian said.

Serena sat on the sofa with an ice pack on her wrist, sniffling. My mother was holding the ice pack for her.

My father cleared his throat. "Evelyn. Apologize to the girl. Tell Adrian you made a mistake, and we can all forget it."

"She burned herself, Dad."

"Enough!" He slammed his palm on the desk. "Say sorry and end this."

Mom didn't look at me. She adjusted Serena's ice pack.

My leg burned. My arm ached under the gauze. The stitches on my forehead pulled every time I frowned. Everyone in that room was waiting for me to crawl.

But I picked up Gordon's pen.

"Evie," Adrian said. Something flickered across his face. Doubt, maybe. "Think about what you're doing."

"I did. For four years."

I signed. Evelyn Hart. Not Vale.

Then I twisted the ring off my finger. It caught on the knuckle, and I pulled harder until it came free.

I set it on top of my signature.

"There," I said. "Now you can finally take care of her without any burden."

Adrian stared at the ring. He didn't pick it up.

Unlock Now
Show your support to inspire the writer to come up with more fantastic stories

He Chose His First Love, Then Begged for My Return

Chapter 1 : Sherry
Chapters
Customize
Next Chapter