Not until morning, when Nicholas kicked me awake.

"Clara, did you really sleep out here all night? I figured you'd crashed at a classmate's place."

"How can one person be this dense? If you couldn't get in, why didn't you just call me?"

"I did. You were too busy playing games with Pat to pick up."

Nicholas paused, then frowned and reached down to haul me up.

My legs had gone numb. I couldn't stand.

I pitched straight into his arms.

His body went stiff, the tips of his ears flushing red.

His expression had only just softened when Pat's voice drifted out from inside.

"Sis, you're back. Come in and eat."

"Mom just boiled some shrimp."

The second he heard that, Nicholas shoved me away and hurried back to Pat's side.

"The bowls are too hot. Leave them, I've got it. You just sit and eat."

Five people, four stools.

In this house, it seemed there had never been a place for me.

Mom froze for a moment, then gave an awkward excuse.

"You never eat on time anyway. We're used to it."

It wasn't that I didn't eat on time. It was that Nicholas and the others finished their homework so fast.

By the time I'd worked through the last big problem, all that was left on the table were cold scraps and a pile of dishes to wash.

Nicholas pulled out the stool for Pat, then set the whole plate of shrimp down in front of me.

"You've got nothing better to do, so go help Pat peel these in the kitchen."

"People with bad grades should at least be good with their hands. Handy for waiting tables at a restaurant someday."

Pat let out a giggle.

"Nicholas, don't be mean. My sister isn't as useless as you make her sound."

"Her math is terrible, sure, but she could still manage as a cashier. Stop bossing her around all the time."

Nicholas didn't even look up.

"No need to feel sorry for her. She's used to all this from her days out in the country. She's not that delicate."

The country was hard. Money was tight, and Grandma was getting old.

I'd been helping with the laundry and the cooking since I was very small.

The stove was too high. I couldn't reach.

Every time smoke rose from a kitchen fire in our house, Nicholas, who lived at the east end of the village, would carry a stool over to help me.

He never tired of telling me the same thing.

"You've got me. What's there to be scared of?"

"I'd never let you go hungry."

Later, Grandma passed away.

Nicholas came with me all the way from the country to the city, and moved into my family's home.

We were closer now, physically, than we'd ever been.

Yet our hearts seemed to drift further and further apart.

A whole night in the cold draft of the stairwell had left my head swimming.

I had no appetite.

Back in my room, I pulled the blanket over my head.

Mom sighed the way you sigh at something you've given up on.

"This child. Throwing another tantrum."

"Same parents, and yet the gap between her and Pat is this wide. How?"

"Sometimes I want to run a DNA test, just to see if they swapped the babies on us back then."

Dad sighed along with her.

"Let her be."

"If she won't rise to it, what can we do?"

"We've got Nicholas and Pat, two children who actually care about us. That's enough."

Pat had grown up at our parents' side, given the best education the city had to offer.

But as far back as I could remember,

the only things beside me were endless fields and my illiterate grandmother.

How could a girl like me ever measure up to Pat, who'd been raised in love?

My head throbbed, foggy and miserable.

I drifted off into a daze.

When I opened my eyes again, the house was pitch dark.

My whole body burned like a furnace.

Out of habit, I called Nicholas's name. No answer.

I texted him. No reply.

I don't know how much time passed before Pat's call came through.

"Sis, Nicholas and I went on a trip, and Mom and Dad couldn't stop worrying, so they tagged along too."

"Oh, it's all my fault. I was in such a rush packing that I forgot to invite you."

Nicholas snatched the phone.

"No need to explain so much to her."

"With a score that low, what nerve would she have to go on a trip anyway?"

"Clara, just stay home and study. Stop thinking about having fun all day."

The line went dead, and everything was pitch-black again.

Back when I was in the countryside, Pat was always messaging me to show off her study tours, her spring outings, her vacations.

Country kids never got to experience any of that.

Every time I saw those messages, I'd ache with envy.

Nicholas would take my hand and smile.

"What's so special about it? Once we test into the city, I'll take you. Anywhere you want to go, we'll go!"

From that moment on, I started writing my wishes down, one by one, in this little plan booklet.

Where we'd go, what we'd do, none of it mattered.

As long as I was with Nicholas, I was happy.

Now the chance was right in front of me.

But Nicholas had left me far, far behind.

I dug out that crumpled plan booklet.

I picked up a pen and put a check mark beside the line, "Get into my dream college."

Then I read down through it, word by word.

"Go to the amusement park with Nicholas and ride the Ferris wheel."

"Visit the city library with Nicholas."

"Take graduation photos and a family portrait with Nicholas."

……

Twenty-nine lines in all.

The handwriting went from childish to neat.

Every single line, we'd written together.

Too bad he didn't remember any of it.

I fished two fever pills out of the drawer.

Once I felt a little better, I called Mark Lane and asked if he knew the address of the city library.

He laughed the second he heard the question.

"The tests are over. What would you even go to the library for?"

"Clara, don't tell me you're actually planning to retake the SATs. Take my advice and let it go. A place like the top university isn't somewhere ordinary people can get into."

"People like us, we're not the same as geniuses like Nicholas and his crowd."

Yes. I knew that.

Chasing after a genius was just too exhausting.

So this time, I only wanted to finish these wishes on my own.

"I'm not retaking anything. I just want to go see it."

My college is over seven hundred miles from Harbor City.

Once I left, I wouldn't be coming back.

But I still hadn't seen the sights of Harbor City.

I wanted to leave without any regrets.

I started tutoring on the side to earn money.

Part of it I set aside for future tuition and living expenses.

Part of it I spent on a dress, and on the amusement park.

When the Ferris wheel reached its highest point,

the evening breeze of Harbor City lifted the hem of my dress ever so gently.

No wonder Pat looked so happy in that photo.

So this was how it felt, standing up high.

I took a picture and posted it to my feed.

Not long after, Nicholas called.

"Clara, what's that photo of yours supposed to mean?"

"What do you mean?"

"Pat just posted her travel pictures, and you turned right around and posted that. Isn't that you deliberately telling everyone that we're leaving you out?"

There was real anger in his voice.

"Delete the post right now and apologize to Pat."

"Because of that photo of yours, she's insisting on cutting the trip short to come back and keep you company."

I idly scrolled down.

Right below my photo was Pat's newest post.

The four of them standing on a mountaintop, smiling like flowers in bloom.

The caption read, “The happiest family in the world.”

Mom, Dad, and Nicholas were the first to like it and comment.

All that noise under their post only made my single photo look lonelier.

I pressed my lips together, and for once my voice came out hard.

“I'm not deleting it.”

It was the first photo where I was the one who mattered.

The girl in it looked lovely.

Even lovelier than that photo of Pat that Nicholas kept saved on his phone.

“Clara, when did you turn into this?”

“So you did poorly on one exam. That's not Pat's fault. Why are you throwing a fit at us?”

“Bad grades are one thing, but there's no excuse for turning into a bad person.”

I hung up.

I had the beach to see soon. No time to argue with him.

Nicholas and the rest of them spent the whole summer traveling.

Pat kept saying she'd come back to keep me company.

But she never stopped updating her feed for a second.

They lit candles at a famous cathedral, wandered old-town streets, watched the first light hit the mountain peaks.

It was through her posts that I finally learned there were places like that in the world.

Too bad none of that brightness had anything to do with me.

On the last day of break, Nicholas finally came back.

With the money I'd earned from my part-time job, I'd scraped together everything I needed for the new term.

When I got home, the whole family was huddled together looking at their vacation photos.

“This one of Pat turned out great. I'm making it my profile picture.”

“We should frame it and hang it in the living room, so everyone can see how amazing my precious daughter is!”

Only Nicholas looked up, his eyes settling on me, dark and quiet.

“Why are you getting back so late?”

“Clara, did you fall in with the wrong crowd out there and go bad?”

Mom and Dad, laughing a second ago, turned suddenly serious.

Dad glared at me, his brow knotted tight.

Mom got up to fetch the ruler.

They were always like this.

They'd believe anyone but me.

At least I'd already crossed the family-photo wish off my list.

And I no longer thought of them as family.

“Three years in this city, and I don't even know what any of it looks like outside of school.”

“The SATs are over now. I wanted to look around a little, to have a taste of the life Pat gets. Is that a crime?”

Going shopping with your parents. Eating out. Seeing a movie.

The little things Pat took for granted.

For me, a girl raised in the countryside all my life, they were luxuries I never even dared to want.

Dad, guilt-struck by my words, slammed his hand down hard on the table.

“You little brat, your wings have grown out, huh? Learned to talk back?”

Mom muttered, grudging.

“This child. How did she turn out like this.”

“If I'd known, I never should have brought her back in the first place.”

I said nothing. I dragged out the suitcase I'd already packed.

Mom and Dad froze.

What followed was a loud, ringing slap.

“The nerve of you, standing up to your own parents.”

“After all these years raising you, this is the thanks I get?”

“If you dare walk out today, don't ever think about coming back!”

I'd never planned on coming back anyway.

This place had never been my home.

I turned and walked out without a moment's hesitation.

As I passed Nicholas, he reached out on instinct to catch my arm.

But once he saw Pat, he quietly let his hand drop.

He had a better choice now.

And I could leave with nothing holding me back.

I drew a deep breath.

I lifted my head and walked out into the long, endless night behind me.

……

Long after she was gone, Nicholas finally worked up the courage to speak.

“Please don't be upset, Mr. and Mrs. Henson.”

“Clara's hurting too, bombing the SATs like that. I'll go talk to her, and I'll do everything I can to get her into the same university next year.”

Only then did the tightness in her parents' faces ease a little.

“You've always been the sensible one.”

“Clara……never mind. What we did back then really was wrong of us.”

“Talk some sense into her for us. It's late, and it isn't safe for a young girl out there alone.”

Nicholas nodded and dialed the number he knew by heart.

What came back was a busy signal.