Chapter 5
"If you knew your boyfriend had betrayed you, would you still hold on, refusing to let go?” Miranda’s voice was light, mocking, her gaze fixed on Emily with a smirk.
But Emily didn’t even glance at Jeremy, who sat beside Miranda, looking uneasy. Instead, her reply was dry and resolute, cutting through the tension like a blade. “Why would I cling to trash?” she asked. “Sometimes, letting go is the only smart choice.”
Without waiting for a response, Emily stood up, grabbed her wine glass and drained it with a single, smooth motion. She set the empty glass down firmly, her gaze unwavering. “Excuse us,” she said coolly, nodding to Cara, who looked ready to burst into applause. “We have more important things to do.”
With that, Emily strode out of the room, Cara close behind, barely containing her smile. Once they were out in the hall, Cara gave her a thumbs-up, laughing. “Now that’s how you shut them down, Em. That was incredible!”
But before Emily could respond, the sound of hurried footsteps echoed from behind. She turned and there was Jeremy, his face twisted in irritation as he caught up with them.
“Emily,” he snapped, his voice laced with frustration. “What exactly was that all about? You show up, throw accusations around and now you’re leaving without an explanation?”
Emily raised an eyebrow, crossing her arms. “An explanation? For what, Jeremy? For finally seeing you for what you are?”
He stared at her, still wearing his typical look of superiority. “This isn’t just some game, Emily. If you’re trying to prove a point, at least make it clear.”
Emily smirked, glancing at Cara. “Cara, wait for me outside?”
Cara hesitated, her gaze flicking between them before nodding. She shot Jeremy a glare, then walked ahead, leaving Emily and Jeremy alone in the hallway.
Emily turned back to Jeremy, her voice calm but sharp. “You think I’m causing a scene? You’re the one who keeps hiding behind excuses and acting like I owe you an explanation for every move I make. That question earlier—the one about a two-timing jerk? That was for you. I just thought I’d finally spell it out.”
Jeremy’s face flushed with anger and he took a step forward, reaching out as if to grab her arm. But before he could, Miranda appeared beside him, stepping in with her usual innocent look.
“Oh, Jeremy, this is all my fault,” Miranda cooed, her voice soft and laced with fake regret. “I never meant to come between you two. It’s just… a game, Emily. I’m sure you understand.”
Emily gave her a long, unimpressed look before replying, her voice laced with sarcasm. “Oh, I understand perfectly, Miranda. You two go right ahead and enjoy yourselves. I don’t mind at all.”
She turned back to Jeremy, her tone cold. “After all, I know how ‘innocent’ your friendship is, right? You’re practically family. Who am I to stand in the way?”
Jeremy’s jaw clenched, something unreadable flickering in his eyes as he took a step forward. “You really think that?”
Emily’s smile widened, though her eyes were sharp. “Absolutely. I have every reason to trust you both. After all, who wouldn’t believe in a friendship as pure as yours?”
Her words left him visibly frustrated, but before he could respond, Miranda gave a sudden, dramatic gasp and stumbled, clutching her ankle as if she were in pain. She whimpered, looking up at Emily with wide, accusing eyes.
“Emily,” she said with a quivering voice, “I just wanted to say goodbye. You didn’t have to push me!”
The entire act was laughably obvious, but Jeremy’s expression turned dark as he immediately leaned down, wrapping an arm protectively around her. “Miranda, are you alright?” he murmured, his voice filled with concern. Then, his gaze shot up to Emily, filled with irritation. “I can’t believe you’d do this, Emily. I thought you were better than this.”
Emily laughed, the sound soft but filled with disbelief. “Are you seriously buying this? Jeremy, she’s faking it. I didn’t even touch her.”
Miranda put on a pitiful expression, a tear forming at the corner of her eye as she clutched her ankle. “Jeremy, it hurts… I think I twisted it. Can you help me?”
Jeremy shot Emily a withering glare as he helped Miranda stand, his voice filled with disdain. “You know, I really overestimated you, Emily. You clearly can’t handle anyone else in my life but yourself.”
Emily’s calm mask finally cracked, but she kept her voice even. “Well, Jeremy, you don’t have to worry about me ‘handling’ anyone in your life anymore.” She took a deep breath, gathering the strength to say the words she’d been holding back. “In fact, I’m done with this entirely.”
But before she could say more, Miranda whimpered louder, leaning into Jeremy’s chest. “Jeremy, please… let’s just go. I don’t want to cause any more problems.”
Jeremy’s face hardened as he glared at Emily, his words cold and final. “You know what, Emily? Just get out of here. We’re done.”
Emily stood still, feeling a final pang of hurt twist in her chest, but she held her ground. “Trust me, I’m not planning on sticking around,” she replied, voice steady.
With that, she turned and walked away, not bothering to look back. She pushed through the door and found Cara waiting for her outside, eyes full of concern.
“Em, you okay?” Cara asked softly.
Emily nodded, finally letting out a shaky breath. “Better than ever, actually.” She glanced over her shoulder once, taking in the last image of Jeremy with Miranda, who was still clinging to him, her face the picture of victory. But Emily felt no urge to fight, no desire to turn back.
Cara wrapped an arm around her, guiding her away from the building and into the cool night. “You know, Em, that was brave. Not everyone can walk away like that.”
Emily gave her friend a grateful smile, feeling the weight of years lift from her shoulders. “Thanks, Cara. I guess I just finally realized I’m done wasting my time on someone who never valued me.”
Cara smiled, squeezing her shoulder. “That’s the Emily I know. Now, come on—there’s a bottle of wine waiting for us at my place and I think it’s time to toast to your freedom.”
As they walked down the street, Emily felt lighter with every step, leaving the pain, the betrayal and the toxic remnants of her old relationship behind. For the first time in years, she felt a glimmer of hope for the future, one where she could finally live for herself.
And as she glanced at Cara, laughing as they talked about nothing and everything, Emily knew she was finally ready to embrace that future—without Jeremy and without regrets.
Chapter 6
Emily walked away from the scene, her steps steady, her heart lighter than it had been in years. She had originally planned to wait until she’d left the city to send Jeremy a final message, cutting ties for good. But after tonight, there was no point in waiting. His heart was already with Miranda.
Standing beneath the streetlights, she took out her phone and typed a simple message:
[Jeremy, it’s over. I won’t be reaching out again. Take care.]
With a final tap, she sent it and blocked his number, exhaling as if a weight had lifted from her shoulders. The thought of breaking up with Jeremy once would have left her feeling lost and devastated. But now? Now it felt like freedom.
When Emily returned to the apartment, Cara was already waiting, sprawled across the couch, her face lighting up as Emily stepped through the door. Without a word, Emily plopped onto the bed and wrapped her friend in a tight hug.
“Cara,” she announced with a grin, “it’s official. As of tonight, I’m single.”
Cara cheered, pulling her into an enthusiastic hug. “Finally! Welcome to the world of happy singles. We’ve got a lot of lost time to make up for.”
***
The next few days were a blur of packing and sorting as Emily prepared to leave the city and everything it held for her. On her last day, she received a message from one of her former professors, asking if she could stop by for a visit. The professor had been a mentor to her and it felt right to say goodbye properly, so she quickly put together a small gift and made her way over.
What Emily didn’t expect was to find Jeremy waiting there, his face darkening when she walked into the cozy living room. The professor greeted her warmly, clearly unaware of the tension in the air.
“Emily, I heard you and Jeremy were having a bit of a rough patch,” her professor said, smiling kindly. “Thought I’d help you two sort things out.”
Emily forced a polite smile, but Jeremy was already glaring, clearly seeing this as something else entirely. Without a word, he grabbed her arm and pulled her outside, his grip tight and unyielding.
“Jeremy,” she protested, wincing as his fingers pressed into her skin. “Let go of me—this is ridiculous!”
He finally released her, but not without a sneer. “So, this is how low you’ve sunk, Emily?” he spat. “Sending some pathetic breakup text and then running to the professor to try to get back in my good graces?”
She was taken aback, her mind spinning. “You think I planned this?” she asked incredulously. “I didn’t even know you’d be here.”
Jeremy’s face twisted with anger. “Of course, you’d say that. One second, you’re begging for a breakup and the next, you’re cozying up to people who can talk me back into giving you another chance. You’re pathetic.”
Emily clenched her fists, steadying herself. The past half-year flashed through her mind, the countless times she’d questioned him, pleading to understand why he was so distant, why he constantly disappeared to see Miranda. Each time, his response had been the same—cold, indifferent and dismissive.
She remembered herself, desperate, crying, pleading with him to stay. “Please, Jeremy, don’t leave me. I’ll be better. I won’t ask questions anymore, I’ll trust you.”
But no more. Emily straightened, her gaze piercing. “You think this is all some game for me? I sent that text because I meant it, Jeremy. I’m done. I don’t know why the professor invited us both today, but if I did, I’d have told them to forget it.”
But her honesty seemed only to fuel his anger further. “Stop pretending, Emily!” he scoffed, his voice dripping with disdain. “This manipulative, careful act of yours is exactly what I can’t stand.”
The insult fell flat, failing to sting as it once would have. Emily’s voice was calm, almost indifferent. “Fine, Jeremy. I’ll be whatever you need to believe I am—pathetic, desperate, or crazy. Because whatever I am, it’s clear I’m not Miranda.”
Jeremy’s face darkened at the mention of Miranda’s name, his jaw tightening as he spat out, “Leave Miranda out of this. She’s the only one who’s had a good word to say about you.”
Emily couldn’t help a dry laugh. “Then maybe I should give her a ‘best friend’ award for all her charity.”
Jeremy’s expression was a mix of frustration and disbelief, but she didn’t give him a chance to respond. She turned and walked away, leaving him standing alone in the professor’s yard.
***
Back at her apartment, Cara was waiting as Emily walked in, her expression a mix of concern and curiosity. “So? How’d it go?”
Emily exhaled, dropping her bag with a relieved sigh. “As expected. Jeremy didn’t believe a word I said. Somehow, in his mind, I’m still the one who’s wrong.”
Cara wrapped an arm around her friend, shaking her head. “Forget him, Em. He’s a coward who can’t handle the truth. You deserve someone who won’t leave you guessing.”
Emily managed a smile, feeling her friend’s support wash over her. “I know. I just can’t believe it took me this long to see it.”
Cara gave her shoulder a squeeze, smiling back. “Well, you see it now. And tomorrow, we’re leaving all this behind. So let’s make tonight count, okay?”
Emily nodded, grateful for the fresh start that awaited her. Tomorrow was the beginning of a new chapter, one where she’d finally be free to be herself. She knew she was done with Jeremy and as she prepared for her new life, she was also ready to reclaim the confidence she’d once had.
Chapter 7
In the thick of their tense standoff, the silence was interrupted by the creak of the courtyard door. Emily and Jeremy turned as Miranda slipped inside, looking every bit the intruder she was. She gave Jeremy a sweet, practiced smile.
“Jeremy,” she cooed, “you left in such a rush this morning that you forgot your wallet. I figured I’d bring it over. It took some asking around, but I found out you were here at the professor’s house.” She blinked innocently, then looked over at Emily with a smile that didn’t reach her eyes. “Oh, Emily, I didn’t realize you’d be here too. Am I interrupting?”
Emily didn’t bother meeting her gaze, her expression cool. “Not at all,” she replied, her voice icy. “I was just on my way out.”
Emily turned toward the house to bid the professor a proper goodbye. She gave him a warm smile, trying to mask the tension in her eyes. “Professor, thank you for everything. Please take care of yourself.”
The professor sighed, a look of concern crossing his face. “Emily, are you and Jeremy alright? I thought you two were planning to get married.”
Emily forced a small smile, but her tone was firm. “I’m sorry, Professor, but I don’t think we’re quite right for each other.”
The professor’s face fell as he nodded, his voice full of regret. “That’s a shame, Emily. I always thought you two made such a wonderful pair.”
With one last nod, she turned back to the courtyard. There, as she expected, Miranda and Jeremy were leaning close, murmuring in low tones that were obviously meant to keep her at a distance. Miranda noticed Emily’s approach and brightened, walking over with a falsely friendly expression.
“Oh, Emily, please don’t take things the wrong way,” Miranda began, her voice syrupy with feigned innocence. “That day at the club, I just sprained my ankle and had trouble getting around, so Jeremy kindly offered to help. You understand, don’t you?”
Emily’s jaw clenched, but she kept her voice calm. “That’s nice of him, Miranda. Though, if you’re here to see the professor, I’m sure Jeremy can show you in.”
Jeremy’s expression darkened and he cut in sharply. “Emily, what’s with the attitude?”