Chapter 2
Not long after I was taken to a separate room, the bell rang—signaling the end of the English exam.
And yet, not a single one of my classmates went home. Instead, they all came running toward me. Leading the pack was Hadley Klein—my best friend slash forever crush.
She was breathless, face flushed, sweating from rushing over. “There has to be a mistake. Cole would never cheat. He’s the top student at our school and he’s already on track for Ivy League. He has zero reason to do something like this!”
One of the exam proctors standing beside me looked moved, letting out a sigh. “That girl really cares about you. She ran straight here to speak up for you the second she finished her exam.”
I let out a cold laugh. “Does she?”
Hadley and I had grown up together, but our worlds couldn’t be more different.
She came from privilege. I didn’t. But she’d never once looked down on me for it. We’d always been close friends.
For the longest time, I believed that if I worked hard enough, made it into a top university, maybe—just maybe—I’d be good enough to stand beside her.
But after the sun sets today, there won’t be a single chance left for us.
Another proctor in the room couldn’t hide her confusion. “You’re a future valedictorian. Why would you cheat? Is this worth throwing your future away?”
I looked up at her, calm and steady and said, word by word, “Because if I didn’t do it, I’d be dead.”
That stunned her.
All the teachers in the room froze. The look on her face said it all—my words had scared the hell out of her.
But I? I was calm. Even smiling faintly. Like what I’d just said hadn’t come from me at all.
Soon, my homeroom teacher showed up, his face thunderous. He slammed his fist down on the window frame from outside and glared at me through the glass with sheer disappointment.
“Have you lost your damn mind?! The college entrance exam determines your entire future—why the hell would you throw it all away by cheating?”
“Your parents work their fingers to the bone every day—long hours at the factory and extra shifts just to scrape together enough for your tuition. And this is how you repay them? By risking everything and getting disqualified?!”
At the mention of my parents, I lowered my head and bit my lip.
Everyone assumed it was guilt—like I couldn’t face the shame of being caught. Which, of course, only made it look more like I really had cheated.
But the truth was, this was the only way I could get into Princeton.
Soon after, the principal arrived and with him came Mr. Haskins from the Princeton admissions office.
The moment Mr. Haskins saw me sitting in handcuffs, he froze.
“Mr. Grady, what are you doing here?” he asked, baffled. “You already secured early admission to our university through the national science competition. Why would you still be taking the entrance exam and…cheating?”
Dead silence followed.
Every eye turned to me.
Hadley looked like a deer caught in headlights. “He already got in?” she asked, disbelief.
Even the principal and my homeroom teacher were shocked. They turned to Mr. Haskins, as if hoping he’d say he’d made a mistake.
“No. There’s no mistake,” he said firmly. “Mr. Grady has been officially accepted into the Physics Department through the competition track. His acceptance letter should be arriving any day now.”
Now the confusion in the room reached a whole new level.
Everyone looked at each other, trying to make sense of it. Why would someone who’d already secured a spot at the top university in the country risk everything to cheat on a test he didn’t even need to take?
“I know!” My homeroom teacher suddenly blurted out, startling everyone around him. “Someone must’ve framed you! It’s okay, Cole. You can tell us the truth. Someone planted those cheat sheets on your desk, didn’t they?”
The principal quickly stepped in, nodding so hard it looked like his head might come off. “That’s right. Cole, if you just say you didn’t do it, we’ll get to the bottom of this and we’ll clear your name.”
All eyes were on me—hopeful, determined, practically begging to believe I was innocent.
And I knew, without a doubt, that if I denied it right then and there, those teachers would move heaven and earth to protect me.
But I didn’t.
Instead, I stared straight ahead, my face blank and said in a flat, emotionless voice, “I cheated. The cheat sheets are mine.”
Chapter 3
My homeroom teacher sank to the floor like his knees had given out, clutching his thighs and slapping the cold tile in disbelief.
“This is disaster! Cole, what in God’s name were you thinking?!”
The principal’s face turned every shade of red imaginable before he pointed a finger straight at me, his voice booming. “So that’s how it is, huh? After everything this school’s done for you? Then don’t blame us!”
“Remember the fifty grand in scholarship money we agreed to release early for your dad’s medical bills?” he growled. “We were just about to wire it over after you took your exams. But, guess what? That money’s off the table.”
That hit me like a freight train.
“You can’t do that!” I shot up from my seat, no longer calm, “That money’s for my dad’s surgery. How could you go back on your word?”
The principal’s face hardened. “Don’t you dare throw that in my face, young man! You brought this on yourself. And for what it’s worth, that scholarship was for Ivy League-bound students only. Are you one of them?”
“I still can be,” I said, gritting my teeth.
“The hell you can!” he snapped. “The cops are on their way to take you in for questioning. You think any Ivy League school’s gonna touch you now?”
Anger boiled in my chest. My hands were clenched at my sides, shaking from the effort of holding myself back.
“Please, sir,” I said quietly. “I can still make it. Just give me a cha—”
He raised his hand, cutting me off mid-sentence, then turned his back on me. I locked eyes with him and in that moment, I knew—his decision was final.
And then—just as things couldn’t possibly get worse—my mom appeared at the door.
She was supposed to be at the hospital, taking care of my dad. But now, here she was, eyes wide in horror, already welling with tears as she spotted the handcuffs on my wrists.
“What’s going on?” she whispered, trembling.
I froze. “Mom? What are you doing here?”
“Your teacher called. Said you were caught cheating on your college exams. I told him he had the wrong person. I told him my son would never do such a thing.” Her voice cracked. “He said if I didn’t believe it, I should come see for myself.”
“You didn’t cheat, did you, Cole?” she asked, her eyes filled with heartbreak.
My chest caved in at the sight of her like that. I opened my mouth, but the words caught in my throat.
Then, chaos broke loose.
A group of reporters came bursting through the hallway, dragging camera crews with them. They shoved my mother aside like she wasn’t even there.
They had been stationed at the gates, covering any news on the SAT. The second they heard the top-ranked student had been caught cheating, they stormed in, they rushed in, shoving microphones in my face as camera flashes exploded around us.
“Are you Cole Grady? You’re the first student in this state’s history to get busted for cheating on the SATs! Do you realize that this scandal will stick your name for the rest of your life?”
“We heard your mock scores were always perfect. Why’d you feel the need to cheat? Care to comment?”
I stumbled back, shielding my eyes from the blinding lights, completely overwhelmed—until suddenly, Hadley jumped in front of me, with the other kids from my school pushing the reporters back and blocking their way.
“Back off! There’s nothing to report here!” Hadley spun around to face me, her expression twisted with rage. “Why’d you admit to cheating? Is this worth ruining your future, Cole?”
Before I could say a word, a police car pulled up outside. The officers stepped in, ready to haul me away.
Chapter 4
“Cole, say it! Say you didn’t cheat!” Hadley’s face went pale. She turned to my mom and shouted. “If you don’t, you won’t get the money for your dad’s surgery tomorrow. Is that what you want?!”
“What?” my mom gasped, clutching her chest.
When she realized the principal had revoked the payment because of the accusation, she broke. My mom’s face crumbled with panic.
“But we promised to pay for your father’s surgery tomorrow,” she cried, her voice cracking. “Please, Cole. Stop saying you cheated. Otherwise, your dad won’t—” she sobbed.
Then, she dropped on her knees. Kids should be the one kneeling to parents. Not the other way around.
“Mom, get up!” My voice cracked. I clenched my fists so hard I felt my nails cut into my palms.
“I’m not getting up until you say it,” she said, voice trembling. “You’ve always been such a good son, Cole. I don’t believe you could ever cheat. But even if you did—can’t you lie, just this once? For your father?”
And Hadley was yelling too, seizing the moment to push me even harder.
“Cole, please! Just deny it. If they take you away now, the reporters will fight for the headlines and your name will be all over the news. Your future will completely destroyed. And your whole family will carry that stain forever. They won’t survive in this city.”
My classmates started chiming in too.
“Come on, Cole—just admit it was a mistake!”
“Don’t throw your future away Cole!”
Their voices grew louder and louder, clashing into each other like a thousand drumbeats. My head felt like it was splitting open. I looked around: my mother kneeling on the floor, my homeroom teacher wiping tears, the admissions officer from Princeton watching me with silent disappointment.
My lips parted. “I…”
“I cheated. I really did.” The words clawed their way out of me, barely above a whisper—but loud enough.
The second they landed, my mom’s eyes rolled back. She collapsed in a heap.
***
The entire scene erupted into chaos.
Hadley rushed at me, shouting, “Do you have any idea what you just did? You’re not just throwing your own life away—you’re going to destroy your parents too!”
I clenched my fists so tightly my nails dug into my skin, drawing blood. The pain kept me grounded, kept me from breaking.
Mr. Haskins from Princeton’s admissions office stepped forward with a heavy sigh.
“Well, in that case…” he said helplessly. “I’m sorry, Mr. Grady, but we’ll have to revoke your admission.”
In a heartbeat, I’d gone from golden boy to convicted cheat. My heart trembled violently. The storm of emotions inside me was so intense I bit my lip hard enough to taste blood.
Still, I swallowed the truth I so badly wanted to scream and nodded, “I understand. Thank you, Mr. Haskins.”
Everyone around me fell into despair.
They had all been so willing to stand by me. All I had to do was say, I didn’t cheat and they would’ve fought the disciplinary committee for me. But I didn’t. I admitted everything.
Sirens howled in the distance. The cops flanked me, hands on my shoulders, ready to lead me out like some criminal.
That’s when the head of the school board’s investigation unit burst into the room. His face was carved from stone. “Wait! Something’s off!” His voice boomed like a gunshot.
My stomach dropped.
Does he know? I thought, heart beating fast.
My homeroom teacher jumped up from his seat.
“What is it, sir? Did you find proof that Cole didn’t cheat?”
“No, it’s worst,” he said, jaw clenched tight, “He’s trying to destroy himself.”