Chapter 4
Marcus Chen's office was all mahogany and leather. Floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking Fifth Avenue. He sat behind a desk the size of my first apartment and looked at me like I was a problem he'd already solved.
"Mrs. Scott." He didn't stand. "I've reviewed the evidence your attorney submitted. I have to say, I'm concerned about the legality of your collection methods."
Gracelyn leaned back in her chair beside me. "New York is a one-party consent state, Mr. Chen. Mrs. Scott was a party to every conversation she recorded."
"The financial documents—"
"Were obtained from joint accounts to which she had legal access." Gracelyn's voice stayed flat. Bored, almost. "The forged statement came through a properly filed FOIL request. Chain of custody is documented. You know this."
Marcus Chen smiled. It didn't reach his eyes. "We'll see what the judge thinks."
He filed six motions over the next two weeks. Motion to suppress the recordings. Motion to exclude financial evidence. Motion to dismiss based on improper collection. Motion to seal the forged document. Each one landed on Gracelyn's desk with the weight of expensive legal strategy behind it.
She dismantled them one by one.
I sat in the gallery during the preliminary hearing and watched her work. She stood at the podium with a single folder and walked the judge through New York's one-party consent statute. Cited three precedent cases without looking at notes. Presented the documentation chain for the forged statement—clerk's stamp, file number, request form with my signature, all dated and verified.
Marcus Chen argued for forty minutes. Gracelyn responded in eight.
The judge denied every motion.
I watched Philip's face from across the courtroom. He sat perfectly still. His jaw tight. Marcus Chen leaned over and whispered something. Philip nodded once. Sharp.
Outside the courthouse, Gracelyn stopped on the steps. "He'll try something else. They always do. But the evidence is solid. It's going to trial."
I nodded. Ran my thumb along my wrist.
"Go home," she said. "Rest. This part is over."
But I didn't go back to Diana's apartment. I took the subway to Manhattan.
---
The real estate agent met me at the apartment with paperwork and a tight smile. "Are you sure? This market—you could get more if you waited."
"I'm sure."
She walked me through the rooms one last time. The kitchen where I'd made a thousand cups of coffee Philip never thanked me for. The living room where Mrs. Scott had declared Azalea's baby a blessing. The bedroom where I'd injected myself a thousand times while Philip slept.
I signed the papers in the kitchen. Didn't look at the numbers. Just signed.
"The buyers want to close in thirty days," the agent said. "Will that work?"
"Yes."
I left everything. The furniture Mrs. Scott had chosen. The dishes I'd registered for at our wedding. The bed. All of it. I walked out with my purse and the leather folder and nothing else.
The subway back to Brooklyn was crowded. I stood by the doors and watched the tunnel lights flash past. When I got off at my stop, I walked six blocks to a building I'd seen listed online. Ground floor. Corner unit. Big windows.
The landlord was waiting. "You're the designer?"
"Yes."
He showed me the space. Empty. Concrete floors. White walls that needed paint. A bathroom in the back. "It's raw. But the light's good."
I walked to the windows. Afternoon sun poured through. I could see the street. People walking. A coffee shop across the way. Life happening.
"I'll take it," I said.
He blinked. "Don't you want to—"
"I'll take it."
I signed the lease standing at the window. My hand didn't shake. When I wrote my business name in the tenant line—a name connected to nothing I'd been before—something in my chest loosened. Just slightly.
The landlord handed me the keys. "Good luck."
I stood alone in the empty studio after he left. The sun moved across the floor. I pulled out my phone and took a picture of the space. Sent it to Diana with two words: *It's mine.*
Her response came immediately: *Proud of you.*
I sat down on the floor. Put my back against the wall. Looked at the empty room that would become whatever I built it into.
For the first time in three years, I smiled.
---
Sophie Hartman called on a Thursday. "I saw your website. I'm looking for someone to design a nursery."
I met her at a café in Park Slope. She was seven months pregnant. Glowing in that way people always said pregnant women glowed. I'd never glowed. I'd just bruised.
"We bought a brownstone," Sophie said. "The nursery is on the second floor. Good light. But I don't know where to start. Everything feels—" She paused. Smiled. "Overwhelming."
"I can help," I said.
She hired me on the spot.
I worked on her nursery for three days straight. Measured the room. Sourced furniture. Chose paint colors—soft gray, warm white, nothing harsh. I positioned the crib away from the window. Put the rocking chair where the morning light would fall. Hung blackout curtains that looked delicate but blocked every photon.
I worked through the nights. Didn't sleep. Couldn't. Every decision felt like I was building something I'd never have. A room for a child who would be loved. Wanted. Safe.
On the third morning, I stood in the finished nursery at dawn. The light came through the curtains soft and golden. The rocking chair sat exactly where a mother would want it. The mobile above the crib turned slowly in the air current from the heating vent.
I let myself feel it. Thirty seconds. The grief. The loss. The two children I would never rock to sleep in a room like this.
Then I locked it away. Picked up my bag. Left.
Sophie called that afternoon. "Leila. It's perfect. It's exactly—" Her voice broke. "Thank you."
"You're welcome," I said.
She posted photos online. Tagged my business. By the end of the week, I had three more inquiries.
I sat in my studio and looked at the messages. Then I opened my notebook and started sketching the next room.
Chapter 5
The deposition room was smaller than I expected. Gray walls. Long table. Water pitcher sweating condensation onto the wood surface. Azalea sat across from me with her attorney—a thin man in an expensive suit who kept checking his watch.
She wore pale pink. Soft fabric that draped just so. Her hair fell in careful waves around her face. She'd done her makeup to look like she wasn't wearing any. The performance was flawless.
Gracelyn sat beside me with three folders stacked in front of her. She opened the first one without looking at it. "Ms. Rivera, I'd like to review some financial documents with you."
Azalea's attorney leaned forward. "My client has already provided—"
"I'm aware." Gracelyn slid a bank statement across the table. "This is a wire transfer from the Scott family joint account. Seventeen thousand dollars. Dated March 15th. Can you confirm you received these funds?"
Azalea glanced at the paper. "I don't remember specific—"
"Yes or no, Ms. Rivera."
A pause. "Yes."
Gracelyn pulled out another document. Then another. Each one a transfer. Each one dated. Each one requiring confirmation. Azalea's voice grew quieter with each answer. Her attorney stopped objecting after the fifth document.
Then Gracelyn opened the second folder.
"This is a receipt from Dr. Chen's cosmetic surgery practice." She placed it in front of Azalea. "Dated March 18th. Three days after the transfer we just discussed. The procedure listed is a rhinoplasty. Total cost: sixteen thousand eight hundred dollars. Paid in full from the same joint account."
Azalea stared at the receipt. Her fingers curled against the table edge.
"Ms. Rivera, can you confirm this is your signature at the bottom?"
Silence.
"Ms. Rivera?"
"Yes." Barely audible.
Gracelyn pulled out another receipt. "This one is dated June 2nd. Breast augmentation. Fourteen thousand dollars." Another receipt. "September 10th. Facial fillers. Three thousand." Another. "November 20th. Laser treatments. Two thousand."
She spread them across the table like cards. A full hand. "All paid from the Scott marital account. All within the three-year period during which Mrs. Scott was undergoing fertility treatments that cost the family over sixty thousand dollars in medical expenses."
Azalea's attorney cleared his throat. "These transactions were—"
"I'm not asking you." Gracelyn's eyes stayed on Azalea. "Ms. Rivera, I'd like to direct your attention to the first receipt. The rhinoplasty. March 18th. Can you tell me what happened three days before that date?"
Azalea's face went pale. "I don't—"
"March 15th, Ms. Rivera. The day Leila Scott suffered a miscarriage after falling down a staircase in the Scott family home. You were present. Do you remember now?"
The room went very quiet.
Azalea looked across the table. Not at me. At Philip.
He sat three chairs down with Marcus Chen beside him. His face was perfectly neutral. He was looking at the wall behind Azalea's head. Not at her eyes. Not at her silent plea for—what? Confirmation? Support? A signal that they were still aligned?
Nothing.
Azalea's gaze held on him for five full seconds. I watched her expression shift. Confusion to understanding to something colder.
She turned back to Gracelyn. "I'd like to consult with my attorney."
"Of course." Gracelyn gathered the receipts and returned them to the folder. "We'll take a fifteen-minute break."
---
I stood in the hallway outside while they conferred. Through the door, I could hear muffled voices. Azalea's rising. Her attorney's trying to calm.
Gracelyn checked her phone. Smiled slightly. "She's scared."
"Good," I said.
"Philip's attorney approached me this morning. Off the record." She looked up. "They want to deal."
I ran my thumb along my wrist. "What kind of deal?"
"Philip testifies against her. Full disclosure on the staircase incident. In exchange, the DA considers reducing his sentence."
I stared at her. "He'd throw her under the bus."
"He'd throw anyone under the bus." Gracelyn slipped her phone back into her pocket. "The question is whether you want to accept."
I thought about Azalea's face when Philip wouldn't look at her. The moment she understood.
"Let him testify," I said. "I want it on record. In open court. In his own voice. I want her sitting there when he says it."
Gracelyn's smile widened. "I was hoping you'd say that."
---
Two days later, Gracelyn deposed Mrs. Scott.
She arrived in a navy suit and pearls. Sat with her spine straight and her hands folded. Looked at Gracelyn like she was interviewing a servant.
"Mrs. Scott, when did you first learn about your son's relationship with Ms. Rivera?"
"I'm not sure I recall the exact—"
"Approximately."
Mrs. Scott's mouth tightened. "Perhaps two years ago."
Gracelyn made a note. "And when did you learn Ms. Rivera was pregnant with your son's child?"
"Last spring."
"Can you be more specific?"
"April. Early April."
Gracelyn pulled out a document. "This is a text message from your phone to Philip Scott. Dated March 20th. It reads: 'Congratulations on the baby. Let me know what you need.' March 20th, Mrs. Scott. Not April."
Mrs. Scott's face didn't change. "I may have misremembered."
"You also stated in your earlier testimony that you learned about Leila's first miscarriage the day it happened. March 15th, three years ago."
"That's correct."
"But Philip testified last week that he didn't tell you about the miscarriage until a month later. April 12th. Which is it?"
Silence.
"Mrs. Scott?"
"I—I may have confused the dates."
Gracelyn leaned forward slightly. "Or Philip lied about when he told you. Which would mean he knew about the circumstances of that miscarriage—including Ms. Rivera's presence—much earlier than he claimed."
Mrs. Scott's hands tightened in her lap. "I don't appreciate your tone."
"I don't appreciate perjury." Gracelyn closed her folder. "We're done here."
---
That night, I sat in my studio and looked at the wall where I'd pinned the trial timeline. Every deposition. Every document. Every crack in their story.
My phone buzzed. Gracelyn.
*Chen called. Philip will testify. Full statement. He's going to bury her to save himself.*
I stared at the message.
Then I typed back: *Good.*
I set the phone down and looked out the window. Brooklyn glowed in the dark. Somewhere across the river, Philip was making the calculation. Azalea was realizing what it meant.
And I was here. Still standing. Still building.
I picked up my pencil and went back to sketching.