Chapter 2

The video disappeared from the front page after three days. But the comments stayed. They followed me to the bodega where I bought groceries. To the laundromat. To the subway platform.

A woman in line at the checkout counter saw me reaching for milk and pulled her cart back like I might contaminate it. She didn't say anything. She didn't have to. The look said everything.

I paid for my groceries and left.

Athena's face was everywhere that week. Magazine covers at the newsstand. A charity gala on Page Six. She wore white to everything — a different dress each time, but always white. In one photo, Keith's hand rested on the small of her back. In another, she was laughing at something he'd said, her head tipped toward his shoulder.

The captions called it a fairy tale.

My phone buzzed one afternoon while I was folding laundry. A text from an unknown number. I opened it.

A photograph. Keith kissing Athena's cheek at some benefit. Her eyes were closed. She looked radiant. The caption underneath was just a smiley face.

I stared at it for a long time. Then I deleted it. Put the phone face-down on the counter. Went back to folding towels.

Later, I sat on the kitchen floor. I pressed my palms together in my lap the way I always did when my hands started shaking. I counted my breaths. In for four. Out for six. I stayed there until the shaking stopped.

I didn't cry. I was past that now.

Keith came to the apartment three weeks after the nightclub. It was late. Almost midnight. I heard his key in the lock and sat up in bed, pulling the blanket around my shoulders.

He stood in the bedroom doorway. He looked tired. His tie was loose. His shirt wrinkled.

"I'm sorry," he said.

I didn't answer.

He crossed the room and sat on the edge of the bed. His hand found mine in the dark. "I know it's been hard. I know I haven't been here. But it's almost over, Elisa. Just a little longer."

His thumb traced circles on my wrist. The gesture was so familiar it hurt.

"I miss you," he said quietly.

Something in my chest cracked open. I'd been so cold for so long. And here he was. Warm. Real. The boy from the foster home. The man I'd married.

He kissed me. Gentle at first. Then deeper.

I let him. I wanted to believe this was real. That the warmth meant something. That the weeks of silence had just been strategy, not indifference.

He pulled me closer. His hands moved over me with a kind of urgency I didn't understand. I tried to slow him down. To ask what was happening. But he wasn't listening.

"Keith—"

"It's okay," he whispered against my neck. "I've got you."

But it wasn't okay. His grip was too tight. His weight was too heavy. I pushed at his chest and he caught my wrists, pinned them gently but firmly above my head.

"Stop fighting me," he said. Not angry. Almost tender. Like he was soothing a child.

I went still. Not because I wanted to. Because some part of me understood that fighting would make it worse.

Afterward, he lay beside me in the dark, one arm thrown across my waist. His breathing slowed. Deepened.

I stared at the ceiling. Counted the cracks. Tried to make sense of what had just happened.

His phone buzzed on the nightstand. Once. Twice. He stirred, reached for it, then got up and walked into the living room. I heard the door close softly behind him.

The walls in this apartment were thin. I'd always known that. I could hear the neighbor's television through the bedroom wall. Could hear footsteps in the hall.

I could hear Keith's voice now. Low. Controlled.

"...it's handled," he was saying. "If she's pregnant, she won't go anywhere. It's a contingency."

I stopped breathing.

"I know the timeline's tight," Keith continued. "But this buys us insurance. She's not going to leave if there's a child involved."

A pause. Then: "Yes, sir. I understand."

I lay perfectly still. My hands were folded on my stomach. I could feel my pulse in my throat.

Keith came back into the bedroom a few minutes later. He slid under the covers, pulled me against his chest, kissed the top of my head.

"Go to sleep," he murmured.

I closed my eyes. I didn't sleep.

I lay there in the dark, listening to Keith's breathing even out beside me, and understood with perfect clarity what had just happened.

He hadn't come here because he missed me. He'd come here because Hezekiah had told him to. Because a pregnancy was a useful tool. Because my body was a problem that needed solving.

I thought about the boy who'd shared a blanket with me when we had nothing. Who'd fought other kids who tried to hurt me. Who'd held my hand in the dark and promised we'd always have each other.

That boy was gone. Maybe he'd been gone for years. Maybe I'd just been too loyal to notice.

I didn't cry. I didn't move. I lay there with Keith's arm around me and felt the last thread of my love pull tight, then snap.

It didn't make a sound.

Chapter 3

The call came at two in the morning. I was awake. I was always awake lately.

"Miss Carter? This is Mount Sinai. Your mother's been brought in. Cardiac episode. You need to come now."

I was dressed and out the door in three minutes. The subway took forever. I counted every stop. Every second.

When I got to the hospital, they told me she needed blood. A rare type. AB negative. They didn't have enough in stock.

"We're calling other hospitals," the nurse said. "But it's the middle of the night. It might take time."

"How much time does she have?"

The nurse looked at me. Didn't answer.

I called Keith. It rang four times. Voicemail. I called again. Again. On the fifth try, I texted: *Mom dying. Need help. Please.*

I paced the corridor. Watched the clock. Called him again.

A different number called back. I answered before I saw the name.

"Elisa." Athena's voice was smooth. Unhurried. "Keith's in a board meeting. He asked me to handle this."

I pressed my hand against the wall. "My mother needs blood. AB negative. I don't know who else to call."

"I can arrange that," Athena said. "I have connections at several blood banks. It won't be a problem."

Something in my chest loosened. "Thank you. Please. As fast as you can."

"Of course." A pause. "But I do need something from you first."

I stopped walking. "What?"

"A video call. Right now. Just a few minutes of your time."

My hand tightened on the phone. "Athena, my mother is dying."

"I know. That's why you're going to do exactly what I say."

The line went silent except for my own breathing.

"I'm sending you a video link," Athena continued. "Answer it. Kneel down wherever you are. I want to see your knees on the floor. Then you're going to slap yourself. Hard. Across the face. And you're going to say these exact words: 'I am nothing. I don't deserve to breathe the same air as Athena Pierce.' Say it clearly. Say it like you mean it."

I couldn't breathe. "You can't be serious."

"Do it, and I make one phone call. The blood arrives in twenty minutes. Don't do it, and your mother dies on that table while you stand in the hallway wishing you'd been smarter."

"Athena—"

"Clock's ticking, Elisa."

The line went dead.

My phone buzzed. A video call request.

I looked down the corridor. A nurse walked past, not looking at me. An old man sat in a plastic chair, asleep. The fluorescent lights hummed overhead.

I answered the call.

Athena's face filled the screen. She was in a restaurant somewhere. Soft lighting. Other people laughing in the background. She looked beautiful.

"Good girl," she said. "Now kneel."

I looked around. The corridor was empty now. Just me and the humming lights and the door to the operating room where my mother was dying.

I knelt.

The linoleum was cold through my jeans. I held the phone up so Athena could see my face.

"Perfect," she said. "Now slap yourself."

I raised my hand. It was shaking.

"Harder than that," Athena said. "I want to hear it."

I slapped myself. The sound cracked through the empty hallway. My cheek burned.

"Again."

I did it again. My eyes watered.

"Now say it."

I opened my mouth. Nothing came out.

"Say it, Elisa. Or I hang up and your mother dies."

"I am nothing," I whispered.

"Louder."

"I am nothing. I don't deserve to breathe the same air as Athena Pierce."

Athena smiled. It was a beautiful smile. The kind that belonged on magazine covers.

"Good," she said. "I'll make that call now."

The screen went black.

I stayed on my knees. My cheek throbbed. I pressed my palms together in my lap and waited.

Twenty minutes passed. Then thirty. Then an hour.

A doctor came out of the operating room. His mask was pulled down. His face was tired.

"Miss Carter?"

I stood up. My legs were numb.

"I'm sorry," he said. "We did everything we could. But the blood we received... there was a mix-up with the type. By the time we realized, it was too late."

I stared at him. "What?"

"Someone sent the wrong type. AB positive instead of AB negative. I don't know how it happened. We're investigating. But your mother went into shock. We couldn't save her."

The corridor tilted. I grabbed the wall.

"I'm very sorry for your loss," the doctor said.

He walked away. His footsteps echoed down the hall.

I slid down the wall. Sat on the floor where I'd been kneeling. My phone was still in my hand.

I opened my mouth. A sound came out. Not a scream. Not a cry. Something worse. Something that had no shape.

I lay down on the cold linoleum. Curled on my side. Pressed my hands over my mouth to stop the sound.

No one came.

I lay there until the lights started to blur. Until the sound stopped coming. Until I couldn't feel my hands anymore.

My mother was dead. I had knelt for nothing. I had debased myself for nothing.

Athena had lied.

And somewhere in Manhattan, Keith Armstrong was still in his meeting.

Chapter 4

Keith called the morning after the funeral. I was sitting on the kitchen floor. I'd been there since dawn. The photograph of my mother — me at seven, holding a paper boat — was on the counter where I could see it.

"Elisa," he said when I answered. "I'm so sorry. I sent flowers. Did you get them?"

I looked at the bouquet on the table. White roses. Expensive. The card was still in its envelope.

"Yes," I said.

"I wanted to be there. You know I did. But the board meeting ran late, and then there was the Pierce Capital merger discussion, and—"

"Athena did it," I said.

Silence on the line.

"She sent the wrong blood type. On purpose. She told me she'd help, made me—" My voice cracked. I pressed my palm against my mouth. Counted to four. "She made me kneel and beg, and then she killed my mother."

"Elisa." Keith's voice was gentle. Patient. The voice you use with children. "You're grieving. You're not thinking clearly."

"I'm telling you what happened."

"It was a hospital error. These things happen. It's tragic, but—"

"Keith, she made me slap myself on a video call. She made me say I was nothing. She promised she'd send the blood if I did it, and then she sent the wrong type. She murdered my mother."

Another pause. Longer this time.

"That doesn't make sense," Keith said finally. "Athena has no reason to do something like that. And no access to hospital blood supplies. You're connecting things that aren't connected because you need someone to blame."

I closed my eyes. "I need you to believe me."

"I need you to trust me," he said. "I know you're hurting. I know this is unbearable. But making accusations against Athena right now — when we're this close to finalizing everything — it's not going to bring your mother back. It's only going to make things harder."

I opened my eyes. Stared at the photograph on the counter.

"Come to the penthouse tonight," Keith continued. "Let me take care of you. You shouldn't be alone right now."

"Okay," I whispered.

"I love you," he said.

I hung up without answering.

I buried my mother three days later in a Brooklyn cemetery. It was raining. The funeral director and I were the only ones there. I stood under a black umbrella that didn't quite cover my shoulders and watched them lower the casket into the ground.

I didn't cry. I'd tried that morning, standing in front of the bathroom mirror, willing the tears to come. Nothing happened. Just the same cold silence that had been spreading through me for weeks.

Afterward, I went to my mother's apartment. The landlord had given me two weeks to clear it out. I walked through the rooms slowly. Touched things. Her reading glasses on the kitchen table. Her sweater on the back of a chair.

I took the photograph from the windowsill — me at seven, squinting into sunlight — and her reading glasses. That was all. Everything else could go to Goodwill or the dumpster. It didn't matter.

I carried the photograph back to Queens and set it on my own windowsill. Right next to the spot where I used to keep the cloth doll I'd made for Keith when we were twelve. The doll was in his office now. He'd taken it years ago. Said he wanted to keep a piece of me with him.

I stared at the empty space where it used to be and felt nothing.

The knock came two weeks later. It was a Thursday afternoon. I was folding laundry in the living room when I heard voices in the hallway. Loud. Excited.

I opened the door.

A man with a camera stood three feet away. Behind him, a woman with a microphone. Behind her, more people. Phones out. Recording.

"Elisa Carter?" the woman asked. Her smile was sharp. Professional.

"Yes?"

"We're from Metropolitan Pulse. We're doing a story on Keith Armstrong and Athena Pierce's upcoming engagement party. We have reports that Keith has been maintaining a second residence here in Queens. Can you comment on your relationship with him?"

My hands went cold.

"I don't know what you're talking about," I said.

The woman's smile widened. "We have sources placing Keith Armstrong at this address multiple times over the past several months. We have photographs of him entering the building. Are you his mistress, Miss Carter?"

The camera was in my face now. The hallway was filling with people. Neighbors opening doors. Watching.

"No," I said.

Something shifted in the woman's expression. Disappointment, maybe. She started to turn away.

I thought about my mother. About the hospital corridor. About kneeling on cold linoleum while Athena smiled.

I thought about Keith's voice on the phone: *You're not thinking clearly.*

"Wait," I said.

The woman turned back. The camera swung toward me again.

I walked into the apartment. My hands were shaking. I opened the drawer where I kept our marriage certificate — the one we'd gotten five years ago at the courthouse, the one Keith said we had to keep secret until the timing was right.

I pulled it out. Walked back to the door. Held it up.

The camera zoomed in. I could see the lens focusing. Could see my own reflection in the glass.

"I'm not his mistress," I said. My voice was steady. Clear. "I'm his wife."

The hallway went silent.

Then everyone started talking at once. The camera flashed. The woman was asking questions I couldn't hear over the roaring in my ears.

I stood there holding the marriage certificate, watching their faces change, and felt something crack open in my chest. Not grief. Not rage.

Power.

For the first time in months, I had said something that mattered. Something that couldn't be dismissed or managed or explained away.

I had told the truth.

And the whole world was about to hear it.

Unlock Now
Show your support to inspire the writer to come up with more fantastic stories

After My Husband Chose His Mistress Over Our Baby

Chapter 2 : Avery Knox
Chapters
Customize
Next Chapter